On 05/12/2013 01:11 PM, Nicholas Leippe wrote:
> I would still use an APC in a data center environment--mounted in metal
> racks above fire-proof floors I wouldn't worry about them venting gas or
> getting hot when they fail. But not in my home on my wood floor or in my
> carpeted office.
>
I don't trust them even in that situation.  I have one that's at least 
30kVA in one of my server rooms.  It was off-line for some time due to 
problems with it's fan controllers, as well as the normal loss of some 
of the batteries.  It was off-line when I first started working here, 
but I get the impression is went out shortly before or after the 
warranty expired.  Eventually it was repaired (on our dime I think), but 
I don't like to use it.  In a power event, if they ever get down to a 
low threshold (like 10% remaining) they shutdown, and require a service 
technician to bring them back up.

I have 4 other Mitsubishi UPSs ranging from 30kVA to 100kVA, and they 
can drain all the way to zero, shutoff, and I can bring them back up 
myself without having to arrange for a service call.  The only problem 
I've ever had was with their original netcom monitors.  After about ten 
years of service a few of the monitors forgot their MAC and start using 
an all zero MAC address.  There was no documented way to reset the MAC, 
nor could I figure it out from the ethernet chip's whitepapers.  
Eventually I gave up and replaced the bad ones with the newer netcom 2 
monitors, and haven't had any trouble since.

I've never had a small desktop Mitsubishi UPS.  I know of another 
systems group that used them for a while but decided to switch to APC 
after a lot of their netcom monitors did the same thing as mine.  That 
was a few years ago, so I don't know if they ever regretted the decision.

Myself, I had a tripplite at home for about three years, and it was a 
good little box.  I don't think the battery was replaceable though.



/*
PLUG: http://plug.org, #utah on irc.freenode.net
Unsubscribe: http://plug.org/mailman/options/plug
Don't fear the penguin.
*/

Reply via email to