[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/PLUTO-672?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Neil Griffin updated PLUTO-672: ------------------------------- Description: The following tests have a {{try ... catch}}} block that assumes {{JspException}} will be thrown when invalid values are specified in portlet related tags. For example: {code:xml} <portlet:renderURL copyCurrentRenderParameters="invalid"/> {code} - [V2PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender_actionURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests2/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender.jsp#L678] - [V2PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender_renderURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests2/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender.jsp#L1131] - [V2PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource_actionURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests3/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource.jsp#L708] - [V2PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource_renderURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests3/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource.jsp#L1161] [Pluto's implementation of portlet:renderURL|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/pluto-taglib/src/main/java/org/apache/pluto/tags/PortletURLTag286.java#L118] defines the copyCurrentRenderParameters attribute as a String, whereas [Liferay defines it as a boolean|https://github.com/liferay/liferay-portal/blob/master/util-taglib/src/com/liferay/taglib/portlet/ActionURLTag.java#L240]. In the case of Liferay, an invalid value like {{"invalid"}} is simply coerced to a boolean. Since there is no requirement in the Portlet 3.0 Spec to throw {{JspException}}, recommend that the tests be removed from the TCK. was: The following tests have a {{try ... catch}}} block that assumes {{JspException}} will be thrown when invalid values are specified in portlet related tags. For example: {code:xml} <portlet:renderURL copyCurrentRenderParameters="invalid"/> {code} - [V2PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender_actionURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests2/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender.jsp#L678] - [V2PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender_renderURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests2/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender.jsp#L1131] - [V2PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource_actionURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests3/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource.jsp#L708] - [V2PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource_renderURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests3/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource.jsp#L1161] [Pluto's implementation of portlet:renderURL|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/pluto-taglib/src/main/java/org/apache/pluto/tags/PortletURLTag286.java#L118] defines the copyCurrentRenderParameters attribute as a String, whereas [Liferay defines it as a boolean|https://github.com/liferay/liferay-portal/blob/master/util-taglib/src/com/liferay/taglib/portlet/ActionURLTag.java#L240]. In the case of Liferay, an invalid value like {{"invalid"}} is simply coerced to a boolean. Since there is no requirement in the Portlet 3.0 Spec to throw {{JspException}}, recommend that the tests be changed to test for either {{JspException}} or a value of {{false}}. > TCK: Contesting tests that expect JspException to be thrown when the > copyCurrentRenderParameters attribute contains a non-boolean value > --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > > Key: PLUTO-672 > URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/PLUTO-672 > Project: Pluto > Issue Type: Bug > Components: tck > Affects Versions: 3.0.0 > Reporter: Neil Griffin > Assignee: Neil Griffin > Fix For: 3.0.1 > > > The following tests have a {{try ... catch}}} block that assumes > {{JspException}} will be thrown when invalid values are specified in portlet > related tags. > For example: > {code:xml} > <portlet:renderURL copyCurrentRenderParameters="invalid"/> > {code} > - > > [V2PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender_actionURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests2/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender.jsp#L678] > - > > [V2PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender_renderURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests2/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests2_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPRender.jsp#L1131] > - > > [V2PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource_actionURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests3/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource.jsp#L708] > - > > [V2PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource_renderURL22|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/portlet-tck_3.0/V2PortletTagLibraryTests3/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/jsp/PortletTagLibraryTests3_SPEC2_26_IncludeJSPResource.jsp#L1161] > [Pluto's implementation of > portlet:renderURL|https://github.com/apache/portals-pluto/blob/master/pluto-taglib/src/main/java/org/apache/pluto/tags/PortletURLTag286.java#L118] > defines the copyCurrentRenderParameters attribute as a String, whereas > [Liferay defines it as a > boolean|https://github.com/liferay/liferay-portal/blob/master/util-taglib/src/com/liferay/taglib/portlet/ActionURLTag.java#L240]. > In the case of Liferay, an invalid value like {{"invalid"}} is simply > coerced to a boolean. > Since there is no requirement in the Portlet 3.0 Spec to throw > {{JspException}}, recommend that the tests be removed from the TCK. -- This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v6.4.14#64029)