2009/2/20 DaveG <[email protected]>: > The summary of the rating should definitely be on the cookbook page. I think > the actual ratings should go somewhere else though (like the Talk page).
To clarify my own position, I'm not actually advocating for rating recipes, but for listing the users of a recipe. Admittedly the message topic might be a bit misleading, as I copied it from the earlier discussion. As for the exact location of where recipe users ought to be listed, I won't insist on having them on the recipe page itself, as long as they're *somewhere*. For now, it's sometimes a little frustrating to develop cookbook recipes as feedback and any indication of recipe usage is so hard to come by. Myself, I've published 15 recipes so far and I have absolutely no idea how many sites are using my code. The idea behind listing users is to provide a maximally easy way to get *any* feedback on recipe usage. Any kind of rating incurs a much greater conceptual load on the brain; essentially you have to ask yourself how good this recipe is and if it's worth your support. In other words, rating a recipe requires you to make a decision whereas declaring that you use a recipe does not. eemeli _______________________________________________ pmwiki-users mailing list [email protected] http://www.pmichaud.com/mailman/listinfo/pmwiki-users
