Sent to you by Sean McBride via Google Reader: Free download of Neil
Gaiman's American Gods via RSSmeme | Stories Published 24 Hours Ago
With At Least 5 Shares on 3/1/08
Shared eight times Tagged Book (118) Copyfight (108)
Neil Gaiman's publisher Harper Collins has put his magnificent novel
American Gods online for free reading as an experiment to see free
digital copies sell print books.
This is a great idea -- it's really exciting to see publishers trying
to get actual data about the market, rather than simply condemning all
copying as piracy and hoping that the Internet just goes away.
However, I think that Harper Collins got this one wrong. They've put
the text of American Gods up in a wrapper that loads pictures of the
pages from the printed book, one page at a time, with no facility for
offline reading. The whole thing runs incredibly slowly and is
unbelievably painful to use. I think we can be pretty sure that no one
will read this version instead of buying the printed book -- but that's
only because practically no one is going to read this version, period.
The fact is that the full text of American Gods has been online for
years, and can be located with a single Google query. I managed to
download the entire text of the book in less time than it took me to
get the Harper Collins edition to load the first page of Chapter One
(literally!). The "security" that Harper Collins has bought with its
clunky, kudgey experiment is nonexistent: pirates will just go get the
pirate edition.
Unfortunately, the "security" has also undermined the experiment's
value as a tool for getting better intelligence about the market. This
isn't going to cost Neil any sales, but it's also not going to buy him
any. We take our books home and read them in a thousand ways, in
whatever posture, room, and conditions we care to. No one chains our
books to our desks and shows us a single page at a time. This
experiment simulates a situation that's completely divorced from the
reality of reading for pleasure. As an experiment, this will prove
nothing about ebooks either way.
It's a terrible pity. Link (Thanks, Spider!)
See also: Which book should Neil Gaiman put online for free?










Things you can do from here:
- Subscribe to RSSmeme | Stories Published 24 Hours Ago With At Least 5
Shares using Google Reader
- Get started using Google Reader to easily keep up with all your
favorite sites

Reply via email to