2014-07-02 2:20 GMT+04:00 Stuart Henderson <[email protected]>: > On 2014/07/01 21:23, Jan Stary wrote: >> > Permission to use, copy, modify, and distribute this software and its >> > documentation for research and educational purpose and without fee is >> > hereby granted, provided that the above copyright notice appear in all >> > copies and that both that the copyright notice and warranty disclaimer >> > appear in supporting documentation, and that the names of the copyright >> > holders or any of their entities not be used in advertising or publicity >> > pertaining to distribution of the software without specific, written >> > prior permission. Use of this software in whole or in parts for direct >> > commercial advantage requires explicit prior permission. >> > >> > >> > - This is not a PERMIT_PACKAGE_CDROM=Yes port. >> >> What would be a more suitable setting of the PERMIT_* values? >> Obviously, I am not a lawyer - could someone please break down >> for me what the license text means for the idividual PERMIT_*'s? >> >> (1) COPYRIGHT is installed with the package, >> containing the copyright notice and the warranty disclaimer >> >> (2) Names of the copyright holders are not used in advertising >> without permission >> >> (3) Putting this on an OpenBSD CD and selling that CD _would_ be >> a "use of this software ... for direct commercial advantage", right? >> >> >> Is (3) the problem? >> Is it at all possible that this would go in the OpenBSD ports tree? >> If so, what should the PERMIT_* be? > > Permission is only granted "for research and educational purpose and > without fee". I'm not too sure how it should be set for ftp etc but > this definitely doesn't allow inclusion on a sold CD. > >> >> Apart from that: >> any comments on the port itself? > > It should be CONFIGURE_STYLE=gnu (I noticed because it used gmkdir > to attempt installing a directory), and NO_TEST=Yes should be removed > (it is meant for ports which fail if you try to run a test, rather > than those which don't have a test but don't fail). Apart from that > and the license marker issue it looks good to me.
Here is updated version, with CONFIGURE_STYLE and NO_TEST tweaked. I also changed CATEGORIES because RTP is not audio-specific protocol, and tweaked PERMIT_* lines due to restrictions in COPYRIGHT file. Still okay to import?
net_rtptools_port.tar.gz
Description: GNU Zip compressed data
