Jeremie Courreges-Anglas <j...@wxcvbn.org> writes:

> Andrew Fresh <and...@afresh1.com> writes:
>
>> On Mon, Dec 26, 2016 at 11:51:32AM -0600, attila wrote:
>>> 
>>> attila <att...@stalphonsos.com> writes:
>>> 
>>> > attila <att...@stalphonsos.com> writes:
>>> >
>>> >> Hi ports@,
>>> >>
>>> >> Attached is a port for the Data::SExpression Perl module.  It is a
>>> >> dependency of the Perl interface I recently contributed to mail/mu
>>> >> upstream, and which will be coming down the pike in some new mu
>>> >> release fairly soon.
>>> >>
>>> >> $ cat pkg/DESCR
>>> >> Data::SExpression is a Perl module that parses LISP-like
>>> >> S-expressions into Perl data structures.
>>> >>
>>> >> Passes make test on i386.
>>
>> Also on amd64, if it is in the "cpan" directory.
>>
>>
>>> >> Comments, feedback most welcome.
>>
>> There is no "cpan" category, need to pick one.  Perhaps devel, or
>> textproc?
>
> Tough.  I'd choose devel/ because the output is perl data structures,
> and because considering s-expressions as text seems far-stretched to me.
> But then, most ports dealing with XML are under textproc/...  your call.
>
>> Don't start off the COMMENT with a capital letter unless it is
>> semantically important (like the COMMENT is the expansion of an acronym
>> or somesuch).  
>>
>> You should add yourself as maintainer if you are interested in that.
>>
>> Should add a test dependency on devel/p5-Test-Memory-Cycle to avoid
>> skipping tests.
>
> Test-Deep should probably go in TEST_DEPENDS instead of BUILD_DEPENDS,
> it's not needed to build the package.
>
>> Some of the newlines in the Makefile can go away.
>>
>> Other than that, it looks OK to me.
>
> Same here.  With the issues above addressed, ok jca@

Thanks a lot for the feedback.  Attached is a revised port that I
believe addresses all concerns raised.  Passes tests on amd64.

Pax, -A
--
https://haqistan.net/~attila | attila@{stalphonsos.com,haqistan.net}
pgp: 0x62A729CF | C2CE 2487 03AC 4C2F 101D  09C1 4068 D5D5 62A7 29CF

Attachment: p5-Data-SExpression-bis.tgz
Description: updated port of Data::SExpression

Reply via email to