Hi Thomas, Thomas Frohwein wrote on Sat, Oct 28, 2017 at 08:43:42PM +0000:
> I managed to build and run fs2open and wxlauncher on openbsd, > successfully running the gog version of freespace 2. > I haven't created any ports before, but this one might be a good start... > > I have 2 questions before tackling this: > > 1) License. fs2open has Volition's custom license > (https://github.com/scp-fs2open/fs2open.github.com/blob/master/COPYING) That's not a license at all, so it is not free software, and if there is nothing else granting rights, you may not be allowed to use the software at all. That said, ports need not be free software. You can provide a port for completely non-free software. You probably have to put something like PERMIT_PACKAGE_CDROM = selling explicitly prohibited PERMIT_PACKAGE_FTP = no license at all PERMIT_DISTFILES_FTP = no license at all > which states: > > "All source code herein is the property of Volition, Inc. > You may not sell or otherwise commercially exploit the source > or things you created based on the source." If no rights are granted in the first place, revoking some of them makes no difference. > There doesn't seem to be a restriction on redistribution. Wrong. Prohibition of selling *is* a restriction of redistribution. But what is worse, right now, i do not see a license *allowing* redistribution at all, and by default, you are *not* allowed to redistribute a Work that others hold Copyright on. You need a license for that. You can still make a port, though. > The community added their contributions apparently mostly without > license (https://github.com/scp-fs2open/fs2open.github.com/wiki/Licensing). What a mess. > Is this still suitable for creating a port? So far, i don't see anything preventing it. You should be aware, though, that ports without PERMIT_PACKAGE_FTP are less useful than those with because everybody who wants to use the port needs to compile it themselves, from the ports tree, rather than just installing a package. > The other piece, wxlauncher, is GPLv2. > > 2) fs2open and wxlauncher are 2 separately distributed pieces of > software. fs2open alone is enough to run the game (provided the > game files are in the right location), but wxlauncher adds a GUI > for graphics/input settings and seems to help with mod support. Sounds like two ports to me, given that fs2open can be used alone. Yours, Ingo
