On 08/06/2017 10:55, Marek Kozlowski wrote:
:-)
Numerous users of my system use forward to external MTAs. From time to
time it causes some issues with SPF on those MTAs. SRS could resolve those.
I'm wondering if you could recommend any SRS software which nicely
integrates with postfix and doesn't interfere with canonicals (postsrsd
does[*])...
We forward our users' incoming mails through our postfix servers to
external MTAs (almost always Gmail). Yes it breaks SPF but it is not
usually a problem, because it doesn't break DKIM. It would of course be
a problem if the external MTAs chose to enforce rejection based purely
on SPF; a very unwise practice IMO, but there may not be much you can do
about it.
In our case (with Gmail as the external MTA) it is only a problem if the
source domain has a 'reject' DMARC policy and the original message,
though passing SPF, fails DKIM (probably because it is unsigned). Our
system monitors the log for such a rejection (by Gmail) and if found
will then encapsulate the original message and re-send it to recipient
(with an explanatory text). In my experience such instances are very rare.