On 27/03/18 03:18, Alex Bruce wrote: > Thing is clamav-milter is a before-queue filter (used as milter in > postfix) whereas ClamSMTP is after-queue filter (uses content filter in > postfix) > > These are fundamentally different ways of providing filtering in Postfix. > > Before-Queue filtering can reject emails if they have a virus in the > SMTP transaction (after DATA) whereas After-Queue cannot or should not > without a bounce message (please no backscatter) so After-Queue should > only quarantine or discard a virus email not reject/bounce. > > Before-Queue requires more memory upfront to handle multiple connections > as each connection is going to need realtime-access to clamav whereas > After-Queue does not have such stringent requirements and can get away > with lower memory as email can be processed slower but not perceived to > be slower (as emails are accepted immediately but later discarded if > virus etc). > > See Pros and Cons of Before Queue -- > http://www.postfix.org/SMTPD_PROXY_README.html > > With clamav-milter it must wait for the milter to say virus or no virus > before it can end the SMTP transaction which leads to potential > performance issues if the mail server is not well speced for > before-queue scanning but it has the advantage of rejecting mail in SMTP > transaction. > > > > From: "André Rodier" <[email protected]> > To: [email protected] > Date: 27/03/2018 12:10 PM > Subject: Re: clamav as a milter > Sent by: [email protected] > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > > > > On 26/03/18 23:35, Scott Kitterman wrote: >> On Monday, March 26, 2018 10:27:57 PM André Rodier wrote: >>> Hello all, >>> >>> Does anyone suffered performance loss when using clamav as a milter for >>> postfix? >>> >>> I would like to scan archives and emails with attachments. Is there any >>> other way to do than using a milter? >>> >>> Thanks for your advices. >> >> I use http://thewalter.net/stef/software/clamsmtp/- it hasn't been updated in >> a long time, but it does what it needs to do. >> >> Scott K >> > Thank you. > > Thank you, Alex,
Now I remember the fundamental difference, I will make sure to use the appropriate one. I might use dovecot sieve and custom scripts as well, I will post on the other list. Kind regards, André -- https://github.com/progmaticltd/homebox
