Hello Ben,

>:)  It's not PowerMail's responsibility that your system is shutting
>down.

Correct.  PowerMail is likely not responsible for causing my system to
crash.  But that isn't the point.  The point is that when a program has
an open file, and is not currently manipulating it, there should be
little to no possibility of corruption.  And that is the responsibility
of each individual program, not Apple.

Think about it this way... each time your System crashes does it tell you
upon reboot that it needs to rebuild the harddrive?  Does it tell you
that all your System preferences are now all corrupt, even for things
that you were not using at the time of the crash?  When you are writing a
Word file and the power cuts out suddenly, do you lose the 8 saved pages
of text in that file or just what you hadn't saved?  If a system crash
happens while Safari or Internet Explorer are open, do you expect that
the next time you reboot that all your saved URLs will be gone?

Of course not.  At least not every time something like this happens.

The truth is that programmers have to assume that unexpected crashes will
happen, including ones the program itself causes.  It's really not a
question of "if", but a question of "when".  So programs that are not set
up to expect the unexpected have a problem that needs to be corrected.

From my earlier stability problems Jerome said "When a crash occurs on
IDLE, there is no rebuild."  That is the correct answer.  Unfortunately,
that isn't my experience.  And since this is happening regularly, that
indicates to me that something is not right with PowerMail even if I am
the only one experiencing this problem.

Steve



Reply via email to