iyah, ngapain sih repot repot.
orang transmigran asal jawa yg diaceh diusir oleh gam, buat apa dipikirin. umat muslim dari aliran tertentu sejenis mahdi, yg ebrtahan di mesjid kota dili, yg diusir oleh pemerintah timorleste, ngapain harus dipikirin orang madura yang diusir orang dayak dari kalimantan tengah dan kalimantan barat, juga buat apa diurusin ? orang ahmadiyah di bogor dan di lombok, yg diusir oleh dewandakwah islam indonesia, fpi, fui, mmi, juga buat apa sih diurusin ? muslim di ambon yg katanya diserbu waktu idul fitri, juga ngapain sih diurusin ? On 11/1/06, Al-Badruuni Enterprise <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Kenapa sih kita repot-repot mikirin "kaum yang terusir" dan tidak punya > tempat tinggal.....? > > > > > RM Danardono HADINOTO <[EMAIL PROTECTED] <rm_danardono%40yahoo.de>> > wrote: > --- In [email protected] <ppiindia%40yahoogroups.com>, "Lina > Dahlan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > wrote: > > > > Penyakit lama. Konteks yang gak nyambung. > > > > 1) Mas Imuchtarom berbicara dalam konteks dan literatur AlQur'an, > > dan mbah dalam konteks wikipedia yang berbahasa Jerman. > > 2) Mas Imuchtarom berkutat pada kata 'Yahudi' itu saja, dan mbah > > berkutat pada 'Budaya Yahudi'. > > > > *** Kalau membicarakan ke Yahudi-an (Yehudim), maka yang terbaik > melihat sisi penggambaran dari sumber umum, misalnya wikipedia, atau > referensi lain, tetapi tidak layak dari agama lain. Kata "Yahudi" > itu saja, tak mempunyai makna apa apa, tanpa mengkaitkannya dengan > kenyataan yang ada ribuan tahun, yakni tradisi, budaya dan agama. > > ------------------------- > > >Sehubungan dengan rujukan yang diberikan mbah, yakni wikipedia, > saya mencoba mengklick yang bahasa Indonesia or bhs Inggris (biar > ngatri gituuu), tapi nyatanya yang bahasa Indonesia tidak sama > dengan yang berbahasa Jerman dan Inggris; begitu juga yang bahasa > Inggris. Saya kira tadinya masing2 adalah terjemahan masing-masing. > Karena saya tertarik akan kitab Musa (1 Mose 12, 1 Mose 32)yang > dikutip di wikipedia berbhs Jerman,tapi nyatanya kok tidak ada di > wikipedia bhs Indonesia or Inggris. > > > > Kembali ke soal kata 'Yahudi' dan penggunaannya, di wikipedia > berbhs Indonesia itu ada dijelaskan bhw istilah ini memang rancu. > Saya setuju dengan apa yang dituliskan dan dijelaskan oleh mas > Imuchtarom yang harus memisahkan dulu dengan jelas, mau bicara soal > Yahudi sebagai agama atau diluar agama (bangsa:Israel, rakyat: > Israel, budaya, bahasa, dll..), karena tidak semua rakyat/bangsa > Israel beragama Yahudi. > > *** Justeru karena kerancuan pemakaian kata ini, saya ajak memakai > referensi yang jelas, apa yang dimaksud dengan kata itu. Kerancuan > ini jelas selali, kalau kita ingat maki makian umat Islam pada > umumnya (ingat kata kata mas Nizami, Ahmadinezad atau yang > lain ), "Yahudi itu buruk, dan harus dimusnahkan". Lha Yahudi apa > yang dimaksud? > > -------------------------- > > Kalau kemudian orang Yahudi (degil) ingin memberikan image bahwa > > Yahudi adalah juga nama bangsa/rakyat, saya kira mereka ingin > > pembenaran atas klaim "Bangsa Pilihan Tuhan" yang tertulis dalam > > kitab suci tersebut (supaya tergenapi). Banyak orang meng-amin-kan > > bhw Yahudi adalah juga suatu bangsa, tapi ketika sudah membaca > kitab suci yang menempatkan 'bangsa yahudi' sbg bangsa pilihan > Tuhan, hati kecilnya meringis,"mana mungkin Tuhan begitu > diskriminatif'??. > > *** nah, anda sendiri sudah ikut ikut menggunakan kata Yahudi yang > rancu. Siapa yang degil? Anda kenal mereka? > > -------------------------- > > [Saya jadi teringat nasehat Nabi SAW,"mintalah fatwa pada hatimu"] > > > > Kembali ke soal rujukan yang digunakan mbah: wikipedia. Buat saya > > rujukan ini masih blur dan tidak bisa dijadikan pegangan untuk > suatu kebenaran karena di wikipedia yang berbahasa Inggris, > Wikipedia jujur telah mewanti-wanti bhw "The factual accuracy of > this article or section is disputed" dan masih diperlukan perbaikan- > perbaikan. > > > > *** TEtap saja kita masih layak memakai sumber ini, daripada secara > emosional mengkritik istilah yang tak ada definisinya. Wikipedia is > not everything, but not that bad. > > ------------------------------- > > > Kalau memang kata 'Yahudi' diambil dari kata 'Jehudim' yang > > berbahasa Ibrani, sebaiknya bahasa Ibranilah yang menjadi rujukan. > > Menunjukkan apa kata 'Jehudim' dalam kamus Ibrani tersebut. > > > > Mengenai silsilah dalam Torah, saya rasa itu hanyalah silsilah > > keturunan bangsa (bukan agama) karena kalau dikatakan Yesus adalah > > dari BANGSA Yahudi, apakah agama Yesus Yahudi juga seperti Musa? > > Lalu, siapa yang mengatakan bhw agama Yesus adalah Kristen? > > **** Ini lagi lagi spekulasi. Tak ada bukti, bahwa tradisi keagamaan > bangsa Yahudi seperti disebutkan dalam Thora adalah berbeda. > > Agama Yesus itu TIDAK ada. Yesus sendiri TAK mendirikan agama. Yesus > jelas jelas menjalankan ritual yang sama dengan leluhurNya sampai > Moses dan sebelumnya, juga David. > > Yang mangetakan agma Yesus adalah Kristen adalah anda. Kristiani > muncul SETELAH Kristus wafat. > > ------------------------------- > > Kalau Musa dan Yesus satu agama, mengapa Musa mempertuhankan Yahwe > (tidak pernah menuhankan Yesus) dan mengapa kemudian Yesus > mempertuhankan dirinya? Kalau Yesus beragama Yahudi, mestinya > pengikut Yesus juga beragama Yahudi (yang tauhid kepada Yahwe) bukan > Kristen. Mintalah fatwa pada hatimu. > > **** Kalau anda cermat membaca riwayat hidup Yesus, maka anda akan > lihat, bahwa sejak lahir Yesus hidup dalam ritual agama Yahudi, > seperti nenek moyangnya. Dia juga berkhotbah di synagoga dan > dipanggil rabbi. Yesus memperbaharui Perjanjian lama (Thora), dan > apa yang Dia ajarkan tertuang dalam Perjanjian Baru, yang bukan > bagian dari agama Yahudi. KeIlahian Kristus adalah bagian dari > ajaran Kristiani, yang BUKAN lagi merupakan agama Yahudi. > > Kembali pada pokok pembicaraan, dimana bung Imuch muncul, adalah > masalah budaya dan bangsa daripada para nabi, yang adalah nabi nabi > Yahudi. > Yahudi dalam literatur Inggris disebut Jew. Dan budaya Yahudi adalah > Jewish Culture. Ini dapat anda baca di library. > > Bagaimana perkembangan dari budaya dan agama Yahudi menjadi > Kristiani lihatlah pustaka dalam bahasa Inggris dibawah ini, yang > walau panjang namun cukup ilmiah (bukan tulisan emosi menggebu yang > sangat mentertawakan). > > Judaism > To complement this article, which was taken from the 1910 Catholic > Encyclopedia, New Advent recommends a prayerful reading of "Nostra > Aetate" from the Second Vatican Council. > > At the present day, the term designates the religious communion > which survived the destruction of the Jewish nation by the Assyrians > and the Babylonians. A brief account of Judaism thus understood may > be given under the following heads: > > (1) Judaism before the Christian Era; > (2) Judaism and Early Christianity; > (3) Judaism since A.D. 70; > (4) Judaism and Church Legislation. > > I. JUDAISM BEFORE THE CHRISTIAN ERA > Upon the return from Babylon (538 B.C.), Juda was conscious of > having inherited the religion of pre-Exile Israel. It was that > religion which had prompted the exiles to return to the land > promised by Yahweh to their ancestors, and they were now determined > to maintain it in its purity. From the Captivity they had learned > that in His justice, God had punished their sins by delivering them > into the power of pagan nations, as the Prophets of old had > repeatedly announced; and that in His love for the people of His > choice, the same God had brought them back, as Isaias (40-46) had > particularly foretold. Thence they naturally drew the conclusion > that, cost what it may, they must prove faithful to Yahweh, so as to > avert a like punishment in the future. The same conclusion was also > brought home to them, when some time after the completion of the > Temple, Esdras solemnly read the Law in their hearing. This reading > placed distinctly before their minds the unique position of their > race among the nations of the world. The Creator of heaven and > earth, in His mercy towards fallen man (Genesis 1-3), had made a > covenant with their father Abraham, in virtue of which his seed, and > in his seed all the peoples of the earth, should be blessed (Genesis > 12, 18; II Esdras 9). From that time forth, He had watched over them > with jealous care. The other nations, once fallen into idolatry, He > had allowed to grovel amid their impure rites; but He had dealt > differently with the Israelites whom he wished to be unto Him "a > priestly kingdom and a holy nation" (Exodus 19:6). Their repeated > falls into idolatry He had not left unpunished, but He kept alive > among them the revealed religion which ever represented God as the > true and adequate object of their devotion, trust, gratitude, of > their obedience and service. > > All the past misfortunes of their race were thus distinctly seen as > so many chastisements intended by God to recall His ungrateful > people to the observance of the Law, whereby they would secure the > holiness necessary for the blameless discharge of their priestly > mission to the rest of the world. They, therefore, pledged renewed > faithfulness to the Law, leaving it to God to bring about the > glorious day when all the earth, with Jerusalem as its centre, would > recognize and worship Yahweh; they broke every tie with the > surrounding nationalities, and formed a community wholly sacred unto > the Lord, chiefly concerned with the preservation of His faith and > worship by a strict compliance with all the ritual prescriptions of > the Law. On the one hand, this religious attitude of the Judean Jews > secured the preservation of Monotheism among them. History proves > that the Persians and the Macedonians respected their religious > freedom and even to some extent favoured the worship of Yahweh. It > remains true, however, that in the time of the Machabees, the > children of Israel escaped being throughly hellenized only through > their attachment to the Law. Owing to this attachment, the fierce > persecutions which they then underwent, confirmed instead of rooting > out their belief in the true God. On the other hand, the rigour with > which the letter of the Law became enforced gave rise to a > narrow "legalism". The mere external compliance with ritual > observances gradually superseded the higher claims of conscience; > the Prophet was replaced by the "scribe", the casuistic interpreter > of the Law; and Israel, in its sacred isolation, looked down upon > the rest of mankind. A similarly narrow spirit animated the > Babylonian Jews, for it was from Babylon that Esdras, "a ready > scribe in the Law of Moses", had come to revive the Law in > Jerusalem, and their existence in the midst of heathen populations > made it all the more imperative for them to cling tenaciously to the > creed and worship of Yahweh. > > Apparently, things went on smoothly with the priestly community of > Juda as long as the Persian supremacy lasted. It was the policy of > ancient Asiatic empires to grant to each province its autonomy, and > the Judean Jews availed themselves of this to live up to the > requirements of the Mosaic Law under the headship of their high- > priests and the guidance of their scribes. The sacred ordinances of > the Law were no burden to them, and gladly did they even increase > the weight by additional interpretations of its text. Nor was this > happy condition materially interfered with under Alexander the Great > and his immediate successors in Syria and in Egypt. In fact, the > first contact of the Judean Jews with hellenistic civilization > seemed to open to them a wider field for their theocratic influence, > by giving rise to a Western Dispersion with Alexandria and Antioch > as its chief local centres and Jerusalem as its metropolis. However > much the Jews living among the Greeks mingled with the latter for > business pursuits, learned the Greek language, or even became > acquainted with hellenistic philosophy, they remained Jews to the > core. The Law as read and explained in their local synagogues > regulated their every act, kept them from all defilement with > idolatrous worship, and maintained intact their religious > traditions. With regard to creed, worship, and morality, the Jews > felt themselves far superior to their pagan fellow-citizens, and the > works of their leading writers of the time were in the main those of > apologists bent on convincing pagans of this superiority and on > attracting them to the service of the sole living God. In fact, > through this intercourse between Judaism and Hellenism in the Gr�co- > Roman world, the Jewish religion won the allegiance of a certain > number of Gentile men and women, while the Jewish beliefs themselves > gained in clearness and precision through the efforts then made to > render them acceptable to Western minds. > > Much less happy results followed on the contact of Jewish Monotheism > with Greek Polytheism on Palestinian soil. There, worldly and > ambitious high-priests not only accepted, but even promoted, Greek > culture and heathenism in Jerusalem itself; and, as already stated, > the Greek rulers of the early Machabean Age proved violent > persecutors of Yahweh worship. The chief question confronting the > Palestinian Jews was not, therefore, the extension of Judaism among > the nations, but its very preservation among the children of Israel. > No wonder then that Judaism assumed there an attitude of direct > antagonism to everything hellenistic, that the Mosaic observances > were gradually enforced with extreme rigour, and that the oral Law, > or rulings of the Elders relative to such observances appeared in > the eyes of pious Judean Jews of no less importance than the Mosaic > Law itself. No wonder, too, that in opposition to the lukewarmness > for the oral Law evinced by the priestly aristocracy -- the > Sadducees as they were called -- there arose in Juda a powerful > party resolved to maintain at any cost the Jewish separation -- > hence their name of Pharisees -- from the contamination of the > Gentiles by the most scrupulous compliance, not only with the Law of > Moses, but also with the "Traditions of the Elders". The former of > these leading parties was pre-eminently concerned with the > maintenance of the status quo in politics, and in the main sceptical > with regard to such prominent beliefs or expectations of the time as > the existence of angels, the resurrection of the dead, the reference > of the oral Law to Moses, and the future Redemption of Israel. The > latter party strenuously maintained these positions. Its extreme > wing was made up of Zealots always ready to welcome any false > Messias who promised deliverance from the hated foreign yoke; while > its rank and file earnestly prepared by the "works of the Law" for > the Messianic Age variously described by the Prophets of old, the > apocalyptic writings and the apocryphal Psalms of the time, and > generally expected as an era of earthly felicity and legal > righteousness in the Kingdom of God. The rise of the Essenes is also > ascribed to this period. > > II. JUDAISM AND EARLY CHRISTIANITY > At the beginning of our era, Judaism was in external appearance > thoroughly prepared for the advent of the Kingdom of God. Its great > centre was Jerusalem, the "Holy City", whither repaired in hundreds > of thousands Jews of every part of the world, anxious to celebrate > the yearly festivals in the "City of the Great King". The Temple was > in the eyes of them all the worthy House of the Lord, both by the > magnificence of its structure and by the wonderful appointment of > its service. The Jewish priesthood was not only numerous, but also > most exact in the offering of the daily, weekly, monthly, and other, > sacrifices, which it was its privilege to perform before Yahweh. The > high-priest, a person most sacred, stood at the head of the > hierarchy, and acted as final arbiter of all religious > controversies. The Sanhedrin of Jerusalem, or supreme tribunal of > Judaism, watched zealously over the strict fulfilment of the Law and > issued decrees readily obeyed by the Jews dispersed throughout the > world. In the Holy Land, and far and wide beyond its boundaries, > besides local Sanhedrins, there were synagogues supplying the > ordinary religious and educational needs of the people, and wielding > the power of excommunication against breakers of the Law, oral and > written. A learned class, that of the Scribes, not only read and > interpreted the text of the Law in the synagogue meetings, but > sedulously proclaimed the "Traditions of the Elders", the collection > of which formed a "fence to the Law", because whoever observed them > was sure not to trespass in any way against the Law itself. Legal > righteousness was the watchword of Judaism, and its attainment by > separation from Gentiles and sinners, by purifications, fasts, > almsgiving, etc., in a word by the fulfilment of traditional > enactments which applied the Law to each and every walk of life and > to all imaginable circumstances, was the one concern of pious Jews > wherever found. Plainly, the Pharisees and the scribes who belonged > to their party had generally won the day. In Palestine, in > particular, the people blindly followed their leadership, confident > that the present rule of pagan Rome would speedily come to an end at > the appearance of the Messias, expected as a mighty deliverer of the > faithful "children of the kingdom'. Meantime, it behooved the sons > of Abraham to emulate the "righteousness of the Scribes and the > Pharisees" whereby they would secure admittance into the Messianic > world-wide empire, of which Jerusalem would be the capital, and of > which every Jewish member would be superior in things temporal as > well as spiritual to the rest of the world then rallied to the > worship of the one true God. > > In reality, the Jews were far from prepared for the fulfilment of > the promises which the almighty had repeatedly made to their race. > This was first shown to them, when a voice, that of John, the son of > Zachary and the herald of the Messias, was heard in the wilderness > of Juda. It summoned, but with little success, all the Jews to a > genuine sorrow for sin, which was indeed foreign to their hearts, > but which could alone, despite their title of "children of Abraham", > fit them for the kingdom near at hand. This was next shown to them > by Jesus, the Messias Himself, Who, at the very beginning of His > public life, repeated John's summons to repentance (Mark 1:15), and > Who, throughout His ministry, endeavoured to correct the errors of > Judaism of the day concerning the kingdom which He had come to found > among men. With authority truly Divine He bade His hearers not to be > satisfied with the outward righteousness of the scribes and the > Pharisees if they wished to enter into that kingdom, but to aim at > the inner perfection which alone could lift up men's moral nature > and render them worthy worshipers of their heavenly Father. The > Kingdom of God, He plainly declared, had come upon His > contemporaries, since Satan, God's enemy and man's, was under their > eyes cast out by Himself and by His chosen disciples (Mark 12:20; > Luke 10:18). The kingdom which the Jews should expect is the Kingdom > of God in its modest, secret, and as it were, insignificant origin. > It is subject to the laws of organic growth as all living things > are, and hence its planting and early developments do not attract > much attenti0on; but it is not so with its further extension, > destined as it is to pervade and transform the world. > > This kingdom is indeed rejected by those who had the first claim to > its possession and seemingly were the best qualified for entering > into it; but all those, both Jews and Gentiles, who earnestly avail > themselves of the invitation of the Gospel will be admitted. This is > really a new Kingdom of God to be transferred to a new nation and > governed by a new set of rulers, although it is no less truly the > continuation of the Kingdom of God under the Old Covenant. Once this > kingdom is organized upon earth, its king, the true son and lord of > David, goes to a far country, relying upon His representatives to be > more faithful than the rulers of the old kingdom. Upon the king's > return, this kingdom of grace will be transferred into a kingdom of > glory. The duration of the kingdom on earth will outlive the ruin of > the Holy City and of its Temple; it will be coextensive with the > preaching of the Gospel to all nations, and this, when accomplished, > will be the sign of the near approach of the kingdom of glory. In > thus describing God's kingdom, Jesus justly treated as vain the > hopes of His Jewish contemporaries that they should become masters > of the world in the event of a conflict with Rome; He also set aside > the fabric of legalism which their leaders regarded as to be > perpetuated in the Messianic kingdom, but which in reality they > should have considered as either useless or positively harmful now > that the time had come to extend "salvation out of the Jews" to the > nations at large; plainly, the legal sacrifices and ordinances had > no longer any reason of being, since they had been instituted to > prevent Israel from forsaking the true God, and since Monotheism was > now firmly established in Israel; plainly, too, the "traditions of > the Elders" should not be tolerated any longer, since they had > gradually led the Jews to disregard some of the most essential > precepts of the moral law embodied in the decalogue. > > Jesus did not come to destroy the Law or the Prophets, that is those > sacred writings which He, no less than His Jewish contemporaries, > distinctly recognized as inspired by the Holy Spirit; His mission, > on the contrary, was to secure their fulfilment. Indeed, He would > have destroyed the Law, if He had sided with the Scribes and the > Pharisees who had raised a fence to the Law, which actually > encroached upon the sacred territory of the Law itself; but He > fulfilled it by proclaiming the new Law of perfect love of God and > man, whereby all the precepts of the Old Law were brought to > completion. Again, He would have destroyed the Prophets, if like the > same Scribes and Pharisees, He had pictured an image of God's > kingdom and God's Messias solely by means of the glorious features > contained in the prophetical writings; but He fulfilled them by > drawing a picture which took into account both glorious and > inglorious delineations of the Prophets of old, setting both in > their right order and perspective. The Kingdom of God as described > and founded by Jesus has an historical name. It is the Christian > Church, which was able silently to leaven the Roman Empire, which > has outlived the ruin of the Jewish Temple and its worship, and > which, in the course of centuries, has extended to the confines of > the world the knowledge and the worship of the God of Abraham, while > Judaism has remained the barren fig-tree which Jesus condemned > during His mortal life. > > The death and resurrection of Jesus fulfilled the ancient types and > prophecies concerning Him (cf. Luke 24:26, 27), and the visible > bestowal of the Holy Ghost upon His assembled followers on Pentecost > Day gave them the light to realize this fulfilment (Acts 3:15) and > the courage to proclaim it even in the hearing of those Jewish > authorities who thought that they had by the stigma of the Cross put > an end forever to the Messianic claims of the Nazarene. From this > moment the Church which Jesus had silently organized during His > mortal life with Peter as its head and the other Apostles as his > fellow-rulers, took the independent attitude which it has maintained > ever since. Conscious of their Divine mission, its leaders boldly > charged the Jewish rulers with the death of Jesus, and > freely "taught and preached Christ Jesus", disregarding the threats > and injunctions of men whom they considered as in mad revolt against > God and His Christ (Acts 4). They solemnly proclaimed the necessity > of faith in Christ for justification and salvation, and that of > baptism for membership in the religious community which grew rapidly > under their guidance, and which recognized the risen Son of God as > its Divinely constituted "Lord and Christ", "Prince and Saviour", in > a real, although invisible, manner, during the present order of > things. According to them, these are plainly Messianic times as > proved by the realization of Joel's prophecy concerning the > outpouring of the Holy Spirit upon all flesh, so that the > Jews "first" and next the Gentiles are now called to receive the > Divine blessing so long promised in Abraham's Seed for all nations. > Much as in these early days the infant Church was Jewish in external > appearance, it even then caused Judaism to feel threatened in its > whole system of civil and religious life (Acts 6:13-14). Hence > followed a severe persecution against the Christians, in which Saul > (Paul) took and active part, and in the course of which he was > converted miraculously. > > At his conversion Paul found the Church spread far and wide by the > very persecution meant to annihilate it, and officially pursuing its > differentiation from Judaism by the reception into its fold of > Samaritans who rejected the Temple worship in Jerusalem, of the > Ethiopian eunuch, that is, of a class of men distinctly excluded > from the Judaic community by the Deuteronomic Law, and especially of > the uncircumcised Cornelius and his Gentile household with whom > Peter himself broke bread in direct opposition to legal traditions. > When, therefore, Paul, now become an ardent Apostle of Christ, > openly maintained the freedom of Gentile converts from the Law as > understood and enforced by the Jews and even by certain Judeo- > Christians, he was in thorough agreement with the official leaders > of the Church at Jerusalem, and it is well known that the same > official leaders positively approved his course of action in this > regard (Acts 15; Galatians 2). The real difference between him and > them consisted in his fearlessness in preaching Christian freedom > and in vindicating by his Epistles the necessity and efficiency of > faith in Christ for justification and salvation independently of > the "works of the Law", that is, the great principles acknowledged > and acted upon before him in this Christian Church. The result of > his polemics was the sharp setting forth of the relation existing > between Judaism and Christianity; in Christ's kingdom, only > believing Jews and Gentiles recline with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob > (cf. Matthew 8:11); they are coheirs of the promise made to the > father of all the faithful when he was as yet uncircumcised; the Law > and the Prophets are fulfilled in Christ and His body, the Church; > the Gospel must be preached to all nations, and then the > consummation shall come. The result of his consuming zeal for the > salvation of souls redeemed by the blood of Christ was the formation > of religious communities bound together by the same faith, hope, and > charity as the churches of Palestine, sharing in the same sacred > mysteries, governed by pastors likewise vested with Christ's > authority, and forming a vast Church organism vivified by the same > Holy Spirit and clearly distinct from Judaism. Thus the small > mustard seed planted by Jesus in Judea had grown into a great tree > fully able to near the storms of persecution and heresy (see EPISTLE > TO THE COLOSSIANS; EBIONITES; GNOSTICISM). > > III. JUDAISM SINCE A.D. 70 > While Christianity thus asserted itself as the new Kingdom of God, > the Jewish theocracy, guided by leaders unable "to know the signs of > the times", was hastening to its total destruction. The Romans came, > and in A.D. 70 put an end forever to the Jewish Temple, priesthood, > sacrifices, and nation, whereby it should have become clear to the > Jews that their national worship was rejected of God. In point of > fact, Judaism, shorn of these its essential features, soon > > "assumed an entirely new aspect. All the parties and sects of a > former generation vanished; Pharisees and Sadducees ceased to > quarrel with each other; the Temple was supplanted by the synagogue, > sacrifices by the prayer, the priest by any one who was able to > read, teach, and interpret both the written and the oral law. The > Sanhedrin lost its juridical qualification, and became a consistory > to advise people in regard to the religious duties. Judaism became a > science, a philosophy, and ceased to be a political institution" > (Schindler, "Dissolving Views in the History of Judaism"). > This new system, treated at first as simply provisional because of > the surviving hope of restoring the Jewish commonwealth, had soon to > be accepted as definitive through the crushing of Bar-Cochba's > revolt by Hadrian. Then it was that Rabbinical or Talmudical Judaism > fully asserted its authority over the two great groups of Jewish > families east and west of the Euphrates respectively. For several > centuries, under either the "Patriarchs of the West" or the "Princes > of the Captivity", the Mishna "Oral Teaching" completed by Rabbi > Juda I, committed ultimately to writing in the form of the Jerusalem > and Babylonian Talmuds, and expounded by generations of teachers in > the schools of Palestine and Babylonia, held undisputed sway over > the minds and consciences of the Jews. > > In fact, this long acceptation of the Talmud by the Jewish race, > before its centre was shifted from the East to the West, so > impressed this Second Law (Mishna) upon the hearts of the Jews that > down to the present day Judaism has remained essentially Talmudical > both in its theory and in its practice. It is indeed true that as > early as the eighth century of our era the authority of the Talmud > was denied in favour of Biblical supremacy by the sect of the > Karaites, and that it has oftentimes since been questioned by other > Jewish sects such as Judghanits, Kabbalist, Sabbatians, Chassidim > (old and new), Frankist, etc. Nevertheless, these sects have all but > disappeared and the supremacy of the Talmud is generally recognized. > The most important religious division of Judaism at the present day > is that between "Orthodox" and "Reform" Jews, with many subdivisions > to which these names are more or less loosely applied. Orthodox > Judaism included the greater part of the Jewish race. It distinctly > admits the absolutely binding force of the oral Law as finally fixed > in the "Shulhan Aruk" by Joseph Caro (sixteenth century). Its > beliefs are set forth in the following thirteen articles, first > compiled by Maimonides in the eleventh century: > > I believe with a true and perfect faith that God is the creator > (whose name be blessed), governor, and maker of all creatures; and > that he has wrought all things, worketh, and shall work forever. > I believe with perfect faith that the creator (whose name be > blessed) is one; that there is no unity like unto his in any way; > and that he alone was, is, and will be our God. > I believe with a perfect faith that the creator (whose name be > blessed) is incorporeal, that he has not any corporeal qualities, > and that nothing can be compared unto him. > I believe with a perfect faith that the creator (whose name be > blessed) was the first, and will be the last. > I believe with a perfect faith that the creator (whose name be > blessed) is to be worshipped and none else. > I believe with perfect faith that all the words of the prophets are > true. > I believe with perfect faith that the prophecies of Moses our master > (may he rest in peace) were true; that he was the father and chief > of all prophets, both of those before him and those after him. > I believe with perfect faith that the Law, at present in our hands, > is the same that was given to our master Moses (peace be with him). > I believe with perfect faith that this Law will not be changed, and > that no other Law will be revealed by the creator (blessed be his > name). > I believe with a perfect faith that God (whose name be blessed) > knows all the deeds of the sons of men and all their thoughts; as it > is said: "He who hath formed their hearts altogether, he knoweth all > their deeds". > I believe with a perfect faith that God (whose name be blessed) > rewards those who keep his commandments, and punishes those who > transgress them. > I believe with a perfect faith that the Messias will come; and > although he tarries I wait nevertheless every fay for his coming. > I believe with a perfect faith that there will be a resurrection of > the dead, at the time when it shall please the creator (blessed be > his name). > With regard to the future life, Orthodox Jews believe, like the > Universalists, in the ultimate salvation of all men; and like the > Catholics, in the offering up of prayers for the souls of their > departed friends. Their Divine worship does not admit of sacrifices; > it consists in the reading of the Scriptures and in prayer. While > they do not insist on attendance at the synagogue, they enjoin all > to say their prayers at home or in any place they chance to be, > three times a day; they repeat also blessings and particular praises > to God at meals and on other occasions. In their morning devotions > they use their phylacteries and a praying scarf (talith), except on > Saturdays, when they use the talith only. The following are their > principal festivals: > > Passover, on 14 Nisan, and lasting eight days. On the evening before > the feast, the first-born of every family observes a fast in > remembrance of God's kindness to the nation. During the feast > unleavened bread is exclusively used; the first two and last days > are observed as strict holidays. Since the paschal lamb has ceased, > it is customary after the paschal meal to break and partake as > Aphikomon, or after-dish, of half of an unleavened bread cake which > has been broken and put aside at the beginning of the supper. > Pentecost, or the feast of Weeks, falling seven weeks after the > Passover and kept, at present, for two days only. > Trumpets, on 1 and 2 Tishri, of which the first is called New > Years's feast. On the second day they blow the horn and pray that > God will bring them to Jerusalem. > Tabernacles, on 15 Tishri, lasting nine days, the first and last two > days being observed as feast days. On the first day they carry > branches around the altar or pulpit singing psalms; on the seventh > day, they carry copies of the Torah out of the ark to the altar, all > the congregation joining in the procession seven times around the > altar and singing Ps. xxix. On the ninth day they repeat several > prayers in honour of the Law, bless God for having given them His > servant Moses, and read the section of the Scriptures which records > his death. > Purim, on 14 and 15 Adar (Feb.-March), in commemoration of the > deliverance recorded in the Book of Esther; the whole Book of Esther > is read several times during the celebration. > Dedication, a feast commemorative of the victory over Antiochus > Epiphanes and lasting eight days. > Atonement Day, celebrated on 10 Tishri, although the Jews have > neither Temple nor priesthood. They observe a strict fast for twenty- > four hours, and strive in various ways to evince the sincerity of > their repentance (see JEWISH CALENDAR). > Reform Judaism, which traces back its origin to Mendelssohn's time, > is chiefly prevalent in Germany and the United States. It has very > lax views of biblical inspiration and bends Jewish beliefs and > practices so as to adapt them to environment. It is a sort of > Unitarianism coupled with some Jewish peculiarities. It disregards > the belief of the coming of a personal Messias, the obligatory > character of circumcision, ancient Oriental customs in synagogue > services, the dietary laws which but few reform Jews observe out of > custom or veneration for the past, the second days of the holy days, > all minor feasts and fast-days of the year (except Hanukha and > Purim), while it uses sermons in the vernacular and adds in some > places Sunday services to those held on the historical Sabbath Day, > etc. Nominally, for all, the Sabbath is the day of rest; but only a > small number even of the Orthodox Jews keep their places of business > closed on that day, owing to the commercial demands of modern life > and the police regulations usually enforced in Christian lands > concerning the ordinary Sunday rest. Intermarriage with non-Jews is > generally discountenanced even by Reform Jewish rabbis, and as a > fact, has never been frequent, except of late in Australia. Of late, > the use of Hebrew has been revived particularly in Palestine Jewish > colonies, and a number of Jewish journals and reviews are published > in that tongue in the East and in certain countries of Europe. > Yiddish, or Judeo-German, is by far more prevalent, and is used in > the large cities of Europe and North America for weekly and daily > papers. > > The Yeshibas, or high schools of Talmudic learning, where the time > was exclusively devoted to the study of rabbinical jurisprudence and > Talmudic law, have been partly replaced by seminaries with a more > modern curriculum of studies. In 1893 Gratz College, thus named from > its founder, was started in Philadelphia for training religious > school-teachers. Young Men's's Hebrew Associations, begun in 1874, > now exist in nearly all the large cities of the United States. Of > wider import still is the development of the Sabbath schools which > are generally attached to Jewish congregations in the same country. > The recent Zionist movement claims a passing notice. Since 1896 the > scheme for securing in Palestine a legal home for the oppressed > Hebrews has rapidly taken a firm hold of the Jewish race. To many, > Zionism appears as calculated to bring about the realization of the > old Jewish hope of restoration to Palestine. To others, it seems to > be the only means of obviating the impossibility felt by various > peoples of assimilating their Jewish population and at the same time > of allowing it the amount of freedom which the Jews consider > necessary for the preservation of their individual character. By > others again, it is regarded as the practical answer to the anti- > Semitic agitation which has prevailed intensely through Western > Europe since 1880, and to the lack of social equality, which Jews > repeatedly find denied them, even in countries where they possess > civil rights and attain to high political and professional > positions. Since 1897 Zionism holds annual international congresses, > counts numerous societies and clubs, and since 1898 has a Jewish > Colonial Trust. There is no Jewish Church as such, and each > congregation is a law to itself. Owing to this, the ancient > distinction between the Sephardim and the Askenazim continues among > the Jews. As of yore, the Sephardim, or descendants of Spanish and > Portuguese Jews, readily organize themselves into separate > congregations. Even now, they are easily distinguished from the > Askenazim (German or Polish Jews) by their names, their more > Oriental pronunciation of Hebrew, and their peculiarities in > synagogue services. > > IV. JUDAISM AND CHURCH LEGISLATION > The principal items of Church legislation relative to Judaism have > been set forth in connection with the history of the Jews. There > remains only to add a few remarks which will explain the apparent > severity of certain measures enacted by either popes or councils > concerning the Jews, or account for the fact that popular hatred of > them so often defeated the beneficent efforts of the Roman pontiffs > in their regard. > > Church legislation against Jewish holding of Christian slaves can be > easily understood: as members of Christ, the children of the Church > should evidently not be subjected to the power of His enemies, and > thereby incur a special danger for their faith; but more > particularly, as stated by a recent Jewish writer: > > "There was good reason for the solicitude of the Church and for its > desire to prevent Jews from retaining Christian slaves in their > houses. The Talmud and all later Jewish codes forbade a Jew from > retaining in his home a slave who was uncircumcised" > (Abrahams, "Jewish Life in the Middle Ages"). > The obligation of wearing a distinguishing badge was of course > obnoxious to the Jews. At the same time, Church authorities deemed > its injunction necessary to prevent effectively moral offences > between Jews and Christian women. The decrees forbidding the Jews > from appearing in public at Eastertide may be justified on the > ground that some of them mocked at the Christian processions at that > time; those against baptized Jews retaining distinctly Jewish > customs find their ready explanation in the necessity for the Church > to maintain the purity of the Faith in its members, while those > forbidding the Jews from molesting converts to Christianity are no > less naturally explained by the desire of doing away with a manifest > obstacle to future conversions. > > It was for the laudable reason of protecting social morality and > securing the maintenance of the Christian Faith, that canonical > decrees were framed and repeatedly enforced against free and > constant intercourse between Christians and Jews, against, for > instance, bathing, living, etc., with Jews. To some extent, > likewise, these were the reasons for the institution of the Ghetto > or confinement of the Jews to a special quarter, for the prohibition > of the Jews from exercising medicine, or other professions. The > inhibition of intermarriage between Jews and Christians, which is > yet in vigour, is clearly justified by reason of the obvious danger > for the faith of the Christian party and for the spiritual welfare > of the children born of such alliances. With regard to the special > legislation against printing, circulating, etc., the Talmud, there > was the particular grievance that the Talmud contained at the time > scurrilous attacks upon Jesus and the Christians (cf. Pick, "The > Personality of Jesus in the Talmud" in the "Monist", Jan., 1910), > and the permanent reason that > > "that extraordinary compilation, with much that is grave and noble, > contains also so many puerilities, immoral precepts, and anti-social > maxims, that Christian courts may well have deemed it right to > resort to stringent measures to prevent Christians from being > seduced into adhesion to a system so preposterous" (Catholic > Dictionary, 484). > History proves indeed that Church authorities exercised at times > considerable pressure upon the Jews to promote their conversion; but > it also proves that the same authorities generally deprecated the > use of violence for the purpose. It bears witness, in particular, to > the untiring and energetic efforts of the Roman pontiffs in behalf > of the Jews especially when, threatened or actually pressed by > persecution they appealed to the Holy See for protection. It > chronicles the numerous protestations of the popes against mob > violence against the Jewish race, and thus directs the attention of > the student of history to the real cause of the Jewish persecutions, > viz., the popular hatred against the children of Israel. Nay more, > it discloses the principal causes of that hatred, among which the > following may be mentioned: > > The deep and wide racial difference between Jews and Christians > which was, moreover, emphasized by the ritual and dietary laws of > Talmudic Judaism; > the mutual religious antipathy which prompted the Jewish masses to > look upon the Christians as idolaters, and the Christians to regard > the Jews as the murderers of the Divine Saviour of mankind, and to > believe readily the accusation of the use of Christian blood in the > celebration of the Jewish Passover, the desecration of the Holy > Eucharist, etc.; > the trade rivalry which caused Christians to accuse the Jews of > sharp practice, and to resent their clipping of the coinage, their > usury, etc.; > the patriotic susceptibilities of the particular nations in the > midst of which the Jews have usually formed a foreign element, and > to the respective interests of which their devotion has not always > been beyond suspicion. > > --------------------------------- > Cheap Talk? Check out Yahoo! Messenger's low PC-to-Phone call rates. > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] *************************************************************************** Berdikusi dg Santun & Elegan, dg Semangat Persahabatan. Menuju Indonesia yg Lebih Baik, in Commonality & Shared Destiny. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ppiindia *************************************************************************** __________________________________________________________________________ Mohon Perhatian: 1. Harap tdk. memposting/reply yg menyinggung SARA (kecuali sbg otokritik) 2. Pesan yg akan direply harap dihapus, kecuali yg akan dikomentari. 3. Reading only, http://dear.to/ppi 4. Satu email perhari: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 5. No-email/web only: [EMAIL PROTECTED] 6. kembali menerima email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ppiindia/ <*> Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional <*> To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ppiindia/join (Yahoo! ID required) <*> To change settings via email: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
