KOMENTAR: Kayaknya seperti cerita "Perompak mencari harta maling" yang pernah ada dalam dongeng bocah angon. Atau dalam cerita western pocket book "Among Bandidos".
----- Original Message ----- From: Yap Hong-Gie To: [email protected] Sent: Saturday, September 22, 2007 8:06 PM Subject: [ppiindia] CORRUPTION: World Bank, U.N. Target Kleptocrats Secara prinsip kita semua setuju dan mendukung penuh semangat hukum yang harus ditegakan. Asalkan hukum yang diterapkan secara murni, jangan dicampur-adukan dan di-intervensi oleh faktor politik. Menunjuk program "Bounty Hunters" PBB dan Bank Dunia, sebelum bernyanyi sorak-sorak bergembira, ada beberap hal yang perlu kita cermati baik-baik. 1. Antonio Maria Costa, executive director of the U.N. Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), mengatakan: "Sekalipun pemulihan dana/aset tersisa sedikit, itu bisa digunakan untuk membiayai program sosial dan infrastruktur" Quote: Recovering even a portion of the stolen assets could provide financing for social programmes or infrastructure. ---End quote. Jadi, statement ini sudah mengkondisikan bahwa, negara yang uangnya dirampok dan dilarikan, jangan berharap dana/aset recovery 100%. Tidak berbeda kalau memakai jasa debt collector; orang harus siap dan rela menanggung ongkos-ongkos operasional, sukses fee sebesar berapa puluh %, tergantung dari tingkat kesulitannya. 2. Reputasi PBB dan Bank Dunia juga sama korupnya dengan target tersangka. Quote: Efforts to clean up also have been hamstrung by scandals involving allegations of fraud and nepotism at the World Bank and in the U.N. system. ---End quote. Lhaa ... kalau dari awal sudah tahu bahwa "Debt Collectornya" engga beres, ya goublok sekali kali kalau masih mau ambil resiko! 3. Program PBB & BD dari awal jelas-jelas mensyaratkan bahwa, dana yang berhasil di recover harus digunakan untuk pembangunan dan kesehatan. Apa dan bagaimana teknis ketentaun yang digariskan PBB & BD, wahualam ..... Quote: The initiative also is intended to monitor the use of recovered assets so that repatriated loot is used for development purposes.---End quote. Sepintas kesannya bahwa program pemulihan aset PBB & BD ini luar biasa mulianya. Seperti halnya dengan program IMF, diawal juga nampak sangat mengiurkan, tapi ada syarat dan kondisi yang mengikat, dimana hasil akhirnya kita semua sudah ketahui. Tapi ada perbedaan prinsip disini, IMF meminjamkan uang kepada pemerintah, sedangkan program recovery PBB & BD adalah pengembalian aset/uang negara. 4. Nah, sekarang puncaknya. Seperti halnya dengan IMF, pemerintah negara bersangkutan akan memonitor habis oleh PBB & BD, agar dana yang di-recover digunakan sesuai pre-conditions yang telah ditetapkan Cuma, ada satu komen dari pejabat PBB yang mengatakan bahwa, pengaman yang ketat perlu dilakukan untuk memastikan agar dana/aset yang dikembalikan tidak dicuri lagi oleh generasi pimpinan yang baru. Quote: "Tough safeguards will be needed to ensure that returned assets do not get stolen again by a new generation of leaders," Costa, the UNODC chief, said in a published commentary.---End quote. Disini kita melihat bahwa, sebelum program ini dilaksanakan, PBB & BD, secara eksplisit dan implisit sudah menyatakan kecurigaan dan tidak mempercaya pemerintahan yang baru. Kasarnya, PBB & BD menganggap bahwa, semua pemimpin negara berkembang (miskin) umumnya maling semua. Ternyata disini kita bukan bicara mengenai hukum, tetapi isunya adalah proyek pemburu harta. Ditambah lagi, hubungan antara kontraktor dengan pemilik (harta), dari awalnya sudah tidak imbang dan tidak ideal. Wassalam, yhg. ---------------- http://www.ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=39291 CORRUPTION: World Bank, U.N. Target Kleptocrats By Abid Aslam WASHINGTON, Sep 17 (IPS) - The United Nations and World Bank launched a bid Monday to strip crooked leaders of the money they steal from poor countries, and to plough the sums into health and development efforts. "From now on it should be harder for kleptocrats to steal the public's money, and easier for the public to get its money back," said Antonio Maria Costa, executive director of the U.N. Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), the world body's agency in charge of the initiative. Bent leaders cheat developing countries of 1 trillion-1.6 trillion dollars a year through smuggling, corruption and tax evasion, according to a report released to mark the launch of the Stolen Asset Recovery Initiative. Recovering even a portion of the stolen assets could provide financing for social programmes or infrastructure. "Every 100 million dollars recovered could fund full vaccinations for 4 million children, provide water connections for some 250,000 households, or fund treatment for over 600,000 people with HIV/AIDS for a full year," the report said. The initiative will seek to prevent the theft by helping developing countries to improve governance and accountability and by urging wealthy countries to stop providing safe havens for the loot. It exhorts countries to ratify the U.N. Convention against Corruption, a 2003 treaty that obliges governments to counter graft of all sorts. Among members of the G-8 wealthy countries, Canada, Germany, Italy and Japan have yet to ratify. Half of the 30 free-market democracies in the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development have ratified the treaty, as have 13 of the 54 jurisdictions classified by the International Monetary Fund as offshore financial centres. These include British crown dependencies such as Guernsey and the Isle of Man; Bermuda and the Bahamas among others in the Caribbean; European states such as Liechtenstein and Monaco; Pacific island states including Samoa and Vanuatu; and parts or all of Djibouti, Malaysia, Panama, and the United States. As with many international pacts, the corruption convention has not been high among many parliaments' priorities. Finance firms and regulators also have voiced concern about reconciling the treaty's requirements against national laws and standards. Efforts to clean up also have been hamstrung by scandals involving allegations of fraud and nepotism at the World Bank and in the U.N. system. Even so, Monday's initiative sets out to bring financial centres into compliance with anti-money laundering legislation that would detect and deter laundering of illicit proceeds, and to strengthen financial intelligence units' capacity to enhance cooperation across the globe. Developing countries will be able to tap the initiative for help in beefing up prosecuting agencies, officials said. Loans and grants will be made available alongside advice to countries lacking sufficient capacity to pursue stolen assets. The initiative also is intended to monitor the use of recovered assets so that repatriated loot is used for development purposes. "Tough safeguards will be needed to ensure that returned assets do not get stolen again by a new generation of leaders," Costa, the UNODC chief, said in a published commentary. "That means monitoring the use of recovered funds by officially recording the receipt of the assets, declaring their intended use, and reporting on expenditure." Significant sums have been siphoned off: Public officials in developing and former Soviet-bloc countries pocket bribes worth at least 20 billion-40 billion dollars a year -- roughly 20-40 percent the value of all official development aid, said the report released Monday. Anti-corruption group Transparency International has estimated that Suharto, who was forced to resign as Indonesian president in 1998, embezzled 15 billion-35 billion dollars from his compatriots. Deceased former heads of state Ferdinand Marcos of the Philippines, Mobutu Sese Seko of the former Zaire, and Sani Abacha of Nigeria pocketed as much as 5 billion dollars each, the watchdog added. Africa loses 148 billion dollars -- 25 percent of its economic output -- to corruption every year, according to the African Union. U.N. agencies said that in the 1990s, corrupt officials pocketed 5.5 billion dollars in Nigeria and three billion dollars in Kenya. Recovering stolen assets can be a time-consuming business: It took the Philippines 18 years to get back 624 million dollars that Marcos had secreted in Swiss bank accounts. (END/2007) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG Free Edition. Version: 7.5.488 / Virus Database: 269.13.28/1023 - Release Date: 22-9-2007 13:27 [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
