Refleksi : Apa pendapat Anda bila peraturan seperti di Arab Saudia diberlakukan di NKRI?
http://www.arabnews.com/?page=1§ion=0&article=120150&d=11&m=3&y=2009 Wednesday 11 March 2009 (15 Rabi` al-Awwal 1430) Khulwa sentence against elderly widow causes uproar Badea Abu Al-Naja | Arab News JEDDAH: The sentencing of a 75-year-old Arab widow to 40 lashes and four months in prison for mingling with two young men, who were reportedly bringing her bread, has sparked fresh criticism of the Kingdom's judiciary and the Commission for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice. Khamisa Sawadi, a Syrian who was married to a Saudi, was convicted and sentenced last week for meeting men who were not her immediate relatives. The two men, including one who was Sawadi's late husband's nephew, were also found guilty and sentenced to prison and lashes. The woman's lawyer, Abdul Rahman Al-Lahem, said he plans to appeal the verdict, which also demands Sawadi be deported after serving her prison term. He said his client has not served her sentence yet. Arab News tried to contact police and the commission officials in Hail, but both refused to give further details about the case. Fariyal King, a legal specialist, said Hail police had a responsibility to explain the case as they detained the two men on the request of officials from the commission. "The Interior Ministry has appointed spokesmen to clarify matters to the media. The Hail police spokesman's refusal to give a statement shows that there is some sort of obscurity," she said. The elderly woman met the men last June after she asked one of them to bring her five loaves of bread, Al-Watan reported. The men - identified by Al-Watan as the nephew, Fahd Al-Anzi, and his friend and business partner, Hadiyan bin Zein - went to Sawadi's home in the town of Al-Shamli. As they came out after delivering the bread, the two men were arrested by commission officials, Al-Watan said on Monday. The court said it based its March 3 ruling on information from citizens and the testimony of Al-Anzi's father, who accused Sawadi of corruption. Sawadi had told the court that she considered Al-Anzi as her son, because she breast-fed him when he was a baby. But the court denied her claim, saying she had no evidence. In Islamic tradition, breast-feeding establishes a degree of maternal relation. Sawadi commonly asked her neighbors for help after her husband died, said Saudi journalist Bandar Al-Ammar, who reported the story for Al-Watan. Suleiman Al-Radhiman, director of the Hail office of the commission, told Al-Watan that his officials detained the woman after receiving a written message that two men had entered her house. "When our patrol team arrived at the site, they found two men coming from the woman's house. We detained the two and handed them over to police for investigation," he said. He pointed out that police had arrested the woman on two previous occasions and a judge in Al-Shamli had convicted her. "The woman asked me to bring bread for her. At that time, I contacted my friend Hadyan who was incidentally passing and he helped me buy bread, as I did not have a car. "After I gave her the bread two commission officials came. They first said they belonged to a charity and wanted to know the living condition of the woman. While we were going out they caught us and handed over to the police," said Al-Anzi. Bin Zein said the commission officials arrested them about 200 meters from the woman's house. "There were six commission members who all had their faces covered," he said. Commenting on the case, lawyer Ibrahim Zamzami said if it was proved that the old woman is Al-Anzi's foster mother through breast-feeding, then the charge of khulwa (illegal seclusion) would be nullified. But if his relation to her is only as his uncle's wife then the charge would stand as she is eligible to marry him. Zamzami, however, warned that the matter of illegal seclusion with an unrelated woman was difficult to prove. "This depends on the circumstances, the time spent together and the way they looked when they come out. The shorter the time spent together, the more likelihood of illegal seclusion," he said. The lawyer said a 75-year-old woman is usually not considered seductive yet she is a woman and unrelated men should not remain alone with her. He said court rulings in such cases are based on Shariah, which did not differentiate between old and young. "Old age is not a sufficient ground for acquittal," he said. Mohammed Nahar, another lawyer, said the two men were arrested on suspicion of committing a sin. "But in law an accused will be innocent as long as the charge is not proved," he said. [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
