Ric Sherlock wrote:
>
> Explicitly defined verbs and verbs that include trains have default rank of
> _ _ _ , but that can be altered as part of the verb definition.

Rick and everybody else still doing this: please stop this misleading
wording!

        A verb's rank CANNOT be "altered".  Its rank is a fixed,
        "intrinsic" property.

As the original poster correctly pointed out (and had to find out
the hard way), applying a rank conjunction creates a new verb with
the new, requested rank, wrapping around the original verb (with
its unaltered own rank still effective).  Any babbling of "changing
ranks" is too much of a simplification, and will give J newbies a
hard time in the long run.

                                                        Martin

[Is there something as a "Frequently Given Complaint"?  I seem to
be sending this message out every five years or so.]

----------------------------------------------------------------------
For information about J forums see http://www.jsoftware.com/forums.htm

Reply via email to