Henry Rich wrote (slightly re-ordered):
> Isn't it plain that you could define a conjunction !.. (rank mu lu ru)
> such that u!..n is the same as u, but with n used as the framing fill?

Martin Neitzel <[email protected]> wrote:
> Frame filling during result assembly happens outside of a verb
> working at its rank mlr.  You simply cannot have your u!..n at the
> same rank as u because it wouldn't stand a chance to look at "fill
> space".  It would have to be at rank _ _ _ .

You wouldn't even need a new conjunction.
You could define m!.v to yield a verb of rank _ _ _
that frames v the same way Rank (either explicit or implicit) does,
except using m as the fill element rather than the default one.

> I wouldn't stick this functionality onto !. because a rank change
> not associated with this modifier otherwise.

There should be no problem with having u!.n and m!.v return verbs of
different ranks (one infinite, one not).
This is already done for u&n and m&v (which are infinite) while u&v is not.

-- Mark D. Niemiec <[email protected]>
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For information about J forums see http://www.jsoftware.com/forums.htm

Reply via email to