Islamic Science
On Christian Strophes in the Koran
In his life's work, German theologian G�nter L�ling challenges
Islam to a Reformation. Wolfgang G�nter Lerch read his book "A
Challenge to Islam for Reformation".
The Koran
Who would have thought that such a remote and difficult
profession such as Koran research would one day become the
hottest iron to cast? Complex studies from the pens of Arabists
and Semitists previously unknown to the wider public have
suddenly come into the line of fire in the era of the "clash of
civilizations", which is in reality a "collision" with Islam. The
fire comes primarily from Muslims who do not perceive academic
insight in this field of endeavor, but rather hostility.
In 2000 the book "Die Syro-aram�ische Lesart des Korans" ("The
Syro- Aramaic Interpretation of the Koran") by a German Semitist
was published under the pseudonym Christoph Luxenberg.
He claimed that the majority of the Koran passages that are
unclear (approximately one-fourth of more than 6000 verses) can
be better interpreted if the assumption is that the Koran
originally took shape in the Aramaic language or in a hybrid
language that was not identical to the high Arabic language,
which was fully developed only much later. Luxenberg thus leaves
out, among other things, the "huris", i.e. the "virgins of
paradise" the Koran promises to the martyrs.
Search for an appropriate interpretation of the Koran
G�nter L�ling, a German orientalist and theologian, has not hid
himself behind a "nom de plume". For forty years he has strived
to find an appropriate interpretation of the Muslims' holy book.
And what he has produced is explosive, in particular for all
those who insist on the inviolability of texts and beliefs.
But to date, it has not been Muslims who have made his life
difficult, but rather his own colleagues. It is telling that the
final version of his life's work on the Koran has been published
in English by an Indian publisher. Even Luxenberg's approach
managed to garner the attention of Arabists and Koran researchers
at a conference in Berlin from January 21st-25th. "We still know
far too little", was the preliminary conclusion.
The title of G�nter L�ling's book already announces his
intentions: "A Challenge to Islam for Reformation." According to
L�ling, the Reformation called for in Islam is not only
necessary, it is also not possible without a critical look at the
holy text in the manner that he, and others, have undertaken.
Koran research has thus also become eminently political. L�ling
continues what had already begun at the turn of the 19th to the
20th century: a Koran exegesis with the historical and critical
methods of Western science, as done before him by Carlo de
Landberg, Martin Hartmann and Karl Vollers. Already at that time
it was hypothesized that parts of the Koran were based upon
Christian hymns.
L�ling's dissertation from 1970, which he published in an
expanded version as a book with the title "�ber den Ur-Koran"
("On the Ur- Koran"), already set out on the path to which he has
remained faithful to this day. This path has led him off the
academic beaten track and into personal hardship because he has
questioned ideas that Muslims have embraced over more than a
thousand years, and also because he has contradicted some of the
main authorities in Koran research.
Revised "Ur-Koran"
As a reviewer of L�ling's book, one cannot help but be astounded
at the abundance of details and arguments in this work of more
than 500 pages; in the end one can only report that it is a
stupendous assemblage of erudition.
In contrast to the new Anglo-Saxon school of Koran research
(Wansbrough revisionism), which is working on versions of the
holy book from two hundred years after the death of the Prophet
Mohammad (632 A.D.), L�ling believes that essential parts of the
Koran existed already before the arrival of the Prophet � i.e. in
the form of Christian hymns and strophic poems.
This is his main thesis, which he understands as a
"reconstruction" of the "Ur-Koran". If L�ling is right, then much
of what Muslims hold to be true would have to be thrown
overboard, namely that the Koran as it appears today was revealed
in toto to the Prophet and was compiled as a largely reliable
text by Caliph Uthman, who ruled between 644 and 656.
It had long occurred to Muslim exegetes that many parts of the
holy book were unclear, and seven different interpretations were
considered tolerable, but the historical and critical methods of
modern science were not available to them.
How does L�ling proceed? He bases his analysis on the extremely
defective writing of early Arabic. As in all Semitic languages,
in his version Arabic in general yields only consonants and long
vowels, the short vowels are left out. Because every letter is
important to the interpretation, the Koran has been given vowels
with the insertion of signs that appeared only much later.
The same is true of the point notations that determine if a
letter is a "b," "t," "th," "n," "s," "sh," "z" or "r," "f" or
"q". Over the course of many generations, the Arabic writing used
today has developed from a suggestive, quasi stenographic writing
system into a "complete" form of writing with the help of
diacritical signs, a process that also occurred with Hebrew under
the Masorets.
No interest in deconstructing Islam
It is easy to understand why misreadings are possible given the
lack of clarity in the writing. Like Luxenberg, L�ling is not
interested in deconstructing the Islamic religion. To the
contrary, he anticipates that his reconstruction of the Ur-Koran
will bring new impulses for Christian-Islamic dialog.
His findings create a bridge between the two religions, a bridge
which�seen in the right way�could hardly be wider. Concerning
the foundations of Islam, it is standard knowledge�even among
Muslims� that biblical and Christian traditions appear in the
Koran, that Jesus played an important role as the predecessor of
Mohammed, as did Mary and the biblical prophets or patriarchs.
Using many new arguments, L�ling has identified important parts
of the Koran as originally Christian hymns (responsories) and has
attempted to reconstruct their exact wording. He uses highly
academic means for this work, which of course also requires
knowledge of pre- Islamic poetry in the Orient, its prosody and
the language forms it used.
There were also Christians among the ancient Arabic poets, and
an entire complex of pre-Islamic or ancient Arabic Beduin poetry
and its language and grammar is among one of the most interesting
and particularly controversial topics in this field of research.
Already in the past century Taha Hussain had expressed doubt as
to the full authenticity of this poetry as it appears today; he
also suspected that there are "metrical compositions" in the
Koran dating from the time before Mohammad. Large protests were
directed against this work. With his own methods, L�ling
approaches texts such as the suras 96, 80 and others.
It would be going too far to quote in detail his reconstructions
of certain "misread verb forms", but these new interpretations
yield many eschatological points with changes in content that
allow for a more insightful alignment with religious tradition
than the older interpretations long considered inviolable. They
thus create continuity in religious history.
Wolfgang G�nter Lerch
The article was first published in "Frankfurter Allgemeine
Zeitung", 1 June 2004
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
--------------------~--> Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo!
Companion Toolbar. Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free!
http://us.click.yahoo.com/L5YrjA/eSIIAA/yQLSAA/KlSolB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~-
>
Yahoo! Groups Links
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
$9.95 domain names from Yahoo!. Register anything.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/J8kdrA/y20IAA/yQLSAA/uTGrlB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->
Post message: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subscribe : [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Unsubscribe : [EMAIL PROTECTED]
List owner : [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Homepage : http://proletar.8m.com/
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/