Kurang jelas motifnya melecehkan Paus Benediktus XVI a.k.a 
Prof Ratzinger - juga merendahkan Yesus dari Paulus. 

Sekurangnya kita dapat gambaran, orang-orang seperti geboy 
itulah yang begerombol ngerumpi di lorong-lorong Basilika St. 
Peter's. Gerombolan yang membuat pecinta Yesus, gerah. 


--- "Roman Proteus" <pt_kasoet@...> wrote:

> Sama Alexander manyun
> Sama Silk Road manyun
> 
> Sekarang sama bung ajeg jontor
> 
> 
> -----Original Message-----
> From: ajeg <ajegilelu@...>
> 
> > terang bulan terang di kali
> > buaya timbul disangka prawan suci 
> > 
> > Seperti biasa, dengan tutur kata yang rapi bak sisiran 
> > rambut Harmoko, si geboy gigih menipu dirinya sendiri. 
> > 
> > Sepintas, kata-katanya yang mengakui Paus Benediktus XVI 
> > DIPROTES keras lantaran (katanya) mengritik Islam, mau 
> > menggambarkan posisi geboy yang fair menyikapi "kritik" 
> > umat Islam terhadap Paus.
> > 
> > Padahal, kalau dia berakal mustinya bertanya-tanya, kok Paus 
> > cuma diprotes keras oleh umat Islam? 
> > 
> > Kenapa bukan pecah perang salib? Atau muncul huru-hara 
> > macam kasus film & kartun Muhammad? Yah sekurangnya-kurangnya 
> > di"Salman Rushdi"kan kek, si Paus itu. Kenapa kok cuma 
> > diprotes keras? Malah apa yang dia sebut protes keras itu pun 
> > kenapa tidak terpublikasi secara luas? 
> > 
> > Dari sini saja sudah tergambar dengan jelas kualitas si geboy 
> > dalam melihat persoalan. 
> > 
> > Tapi, lebih jauh lagi, ini justru membuktikan dengan gamblang 
> > bagaimana sesungguhnya umat Islam memandang dunia. Maksudnya, 
> > orang dengan cara pandang manusia biasa pasti percaya bahwa 
> > diskusi dengan landasan kemanusiaan bakal melahirkan pemahaman 
> > yang sama. 
> > 
> > Sebagai contoh, manusia biasa akan melihat pidato Paus di aula 
> > Universitas Regensburg itu sebagai ceramah dari seorang profesor 
> > belaka. Profesor yang sedang bergembira mendapatkan kesempatan 
> > untuk berceramah di podium kampus lagi. Sebab, dalam ceramah itu 
> > Paus membuka dengan celoteh tentang kenangan manisnya ketika 
> > mengajar di Universitas Bonn. 
> > 
> > Jadi, sangat penting bagi kita untuk memandang Paus di podium 
> > kampus itu sebagai seorang profesor. Profesor yang melakukan 
> > pendekatan terhadap masalah (dhi, Islam) dengan metode ajakan 
> > mencari tahu, dan bukan dengan petentengan sok tahu. 
> > 
> > Ini bisa dilihat dari isi ceramahnya yang bagi umat Islam 
> > mengandung "kelucuan". Lucu karena ketidakpahamannya, 
> > ketidaktahuannya, dan bukan sengaja melucu untuk membungkus 
> > satir apalagi kritik. 
> > 
> > Di antara kelucuan itu ialah (kita anggap geboy punya transkrip 
> > ceramah tsb), Paus Benediktus XVI menyebut QS 2:256 (tentang 
> > tidak ada paksaan dalam beragama) sebagai ayat yang dirilis pada 
> > periode awal kerasulan Muhammad. "When Mohammed was still 
> > powerless and under threat," demikian kata Paus. 
> > 
> > Umat Islam segera maklum, Paus pasti terkecoh dengan nomor 
> > punggung "2" yang dikenakan Surat Al-Baqarah itu. Sehingga wajar 
> > kalau dia menyangka QS 2:256 itu terbit di awal kerasulan 
> > Muhammad. 
> > 
> > Padahal, siapa pun yang pernah buka Al-qur'an pasti tau bahwa 
> > Surat Al-Baqarah tergolong surat Madaniyah; surat yang diturunkan 
> > di episode setelah Muhammad hijrah ke Madinah. 
> >
> > Artinya, QS 2:256 itu turun justru di saat posisi Muhammad dan 
> > pengikutnya sangat kuat, karena harus menertibkan situasi Madinah 
> > yang kacau oleh pertikaian Arab (bukan Islam) vs Yahudi kaki-
> > tangan Bizantium / Romawi Timur. 
> > 
> > Konteks penyebutan QS 2:256 dalam ceramah itu adalah sebagai 
> > tanggapan Paus atas pernyataan Manuel II Paleologus (Kaisar 
> > Bizantium) yang dipajang si geboy di awal joget stripteasenya 
> > di bawah itu ("Show me just what Muhammad brought blabla..."). 
> > 
> > Dalam ceramah itu Paus menyebut pernyataan si Manuel II (tolong 
> > dibedakan dengan pelem emmanuelle-2, sylvia kristel) sebagai 
> > "a brusqueness that we find unacceptable, on the central question 
> > about the relationship between religion and violence in general."
> >
> > Jelas dan gamblang, bahwa ceramah Paus Benediktus XVI di 
> > Regensburg itu justru mengritik bacotannya si Manuel II (non 
> > kristel). 
> >
> > Jadi, bukan, samasekali bukan, mengritik Islam sebagaimana 
> > cuwawakannya si geboy tralala yang rupanya tidak membaca artikel 
> > yang dikirimnya sendiri itu, yang sudah menjelaskan bahwa Paus 
> > tidak mendukung maupun mengutuk pernyataan si Manuel II, selain 
> > menyebutnya sebagai "a brusqueness" dalam hubungan antaragama. 
> >
> > Dalam bahasa akademiknya, ceramah Paus Benediktus itu jelas 
> > masuk kategori pendekatan masalah dengan pertanyaan / ajakan 
> > yang diajukan secara diplomatis. 
> > 
> > Faktanya, ceramah itu ikut membuat kunjungan bersejarah Paus 
> > ke Turki (dua bulan kemudian) semakin mulus, lancar, tanpa 
> > gangguan samasekali, kecuali justru mengundang dengung di lorong-
> > lorong Basilika St. Peter's. 
> > 
> > Nah, sekalipun kali ini si geboy tidak cuwawakan soal sex ("cabut-
> > jangan.." dll), tapi kegatelannya seperti yang dulu. Masih belom 
> > belajar menahan diri untuk tidak nyopotin beha & celdam di muka 
> > umum. 
> > 
> > Atau jangan-jangan situ juga mengidap OCD, boy?
> >
> > 
> > --- Gabriella Rantau <gkrantau@> wrote:
> > 
> > > Beberapa waktu lalu Grek dlm postingnya yg berjudul Paus Masuk 
> > > Islam dan disertai himbauan agar yg membaca menyebar luaskan 
> > > klaim orang2 dungu bhw Pope Benedict mengundurkan diri dan 
> > > masuk Islam.
> > > 
> > > Untuk keseimbangan pendapat aku sertakan artikel mengenai 
> > > pidato Paus Benedict yg DIPROTES keras oleh umat Islam karena 
> > > beliau dlm pidatonya mengritik Islam. Yg ingin lebih banyak 
> > > membaca ttg pendapat dia mengenai Islam aku anjurkan untuk 
> > > click 'Pope Benedict's speech on Islam' atau 'Pope Benedict's 
> > > criticism of Islam'
> > > 
> > > Gabriella
> > > 
> > > POPE BENEDICT CRITICIZES ISLAM
> > > (Artinya dia tidak menjadi mualaf)
> > >  
> > > "Show me just what Muhammad brought that was
> > > new, and thereyou will find things only evil and inhuman, such 
> > > as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached."
> > > These words, expressed six centuries ago by a Byzantine 
> > > emperor, Manuel II Paleologus, in dialogue with an Iranian 
> > > scholar, spur three reflections.
> > > Pope Benedict XVI offered the above quote, neither endorsing 
> > > nor condemning it, in his academic speech, "Faith, Reason and 
> > > the University: Memories and Reflections," delivered in German 
> > > last week in Germany. It served to introduce his erudite 
> > > critique of the Western concept of reason since the 
> > > Enlightenment.
> > > But did he have other purposes? The head of the Benedictine 
> > > order, Abbot Notker Wolf, understood the pope's quote as "a 
> > > blatant allusion to [Iran's President Mahmoud] Ahmadinejad." 
> > > Vatican insiders told the LondonSunday Times that Benedict "was 
> > > trying to pre-empt an aggressive letter aimed at the papacy by 
> > > the president of Iran, which was why he cited the debate 
> > > involving a Persian."
> > > First reflection: Benedict has offered elusive comments, brief 
> > > statements, and now this delphic quotation, but he has not 
> > > provided a much-needed major statement on this vital topic of 
> > > Islam. One hopes it is in the offing.
> > > Whatever the pope's purpose, he prompted the near-predictable 
> > > furor in the Muslim world.
> > > Religious and political authorities widely condemned the 
> > > speech, with some calling for violence.
> > > 
> > > Â Â Â  * In Britain, while leading a rally outside Westminster 
> > > Cathedral, Anjem Choudary of Al-Ghurabaa called for the pope 
> > > "to be subject to capital punishment." 
> > >     * In Iraq, the Mujahideen's Army threatened to "smash 
> > > the crosses in the house of the dog from Rome" and other groups 
> > > made blood-curdling threats. 
> > >     * In Kuwait, an important website called for violent 
> > > retribution against Catholics. 
> > >     * In Somalia, the religious leader Abubukar Hassan Malin 
> > > urged Muslims to "hunt down" the pope and kill him "on the 
> > > spot." 
> > >     * In India, a leading imam, Syed Ahmed Bukhari, called 
> > > on Muslims to "respond in a manner which forces the pope to 
> > > apologise." 
> > >     * A top Al-Qaeda figure announced that "the infidelity 
> > > and tyranny of the pope will only be stopped by a major 
> > > attack." 
> > > The Vatican responded by establishing an extraordinary and 
> > > unprecedented security cordon around the pope. Further away, 
> > > the incitement spurred some violence, with more likely on the 
> > > way. 
> > > Seven churches were attacked in the West Bank and Gaza, one in 
> > > Basra, Iraq (prompting this ironic headline at the "RedState" 
> > > blog: 
> > > "Pope implies Islam a violent religion ... Muslims bomb 
> > > churches"). 
> > > The murder of an Italian nun in Somalia and two Assyrians in 
> > > Iraq also appear connected.
> > > Second reflection: this new round of Muslim outrage, violence, 
> > > and murder has a by-now routine quality. Earlier versions 
> > > occurred in 1989 (in response to Salman Rushdie's novel, The 
> > > Satanic Verses), 1997 (when the U.S. Supreme Court did not take 
> > > down a representation of Muhammad), 2002 (when Jerry Falwell 
> > > called Muhammad a terrorist), 2005 (the fraudulent Koran-
> > > flushing episode), and February 2006 (the Danish cartoon 
> > > incident).
> > > Vatican leaders tried to defuse the pope's quote, as well as 
> > > his condemnation of jihad (holy war). The papal spokesman, 
> > > Federico Lombardi, S.J., said Benedict did not intend to give 
> > > "an interpretation of Islam as violent. … inside Islam 
> > > there are many different positions and there are many positions 
> > > that are not violent." Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, the secretary 
> > > of state, indicated that the pope "sincerely regrets that 
> > > certain passages of his address could have sounded offensive to 
> > > the sensitivities of the Muslim faithful."
> > > Then, in what may be an unprecedented step by a pope, Benedict 
> > > himself proffered the sort of semi-apology often favored by 
> > > those feeling the heat. "I am deeply sorry for the reactions in 
> > > some countries to a few passages of my address," reads the 
> > > official Vatican translation into English, "which were 
> > > considered offensive to the sensibility of Muslims.
> > > These in fact were a quotation from a medieval text, which do 
> > > not in any way express my personal thought."
> > > In the Italian original, however, Benedict says only sono 
> > > rammaricato, which translates as "I am disappointed" or "I 
> > > regret."
> > > Third reflection: the Muslim uproar has a goal: to prohibit 
> > > criticism of Islam by Christians and thereby to impose Shariah 
> > > norms on the West. Should Westerners accept this central tenet 
> > > of Islamic law, others will surely follow.
> > > Retaining free speech about Islam, therefore, represents a 
> > > critical defense against the imposition of an Islamic order.
> > 
> > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
> >
> 




------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke