Defending ‘The Life of Brian’
Gwynne Dyer, Arab News

“Without this there would be no Life of Brian,” said Roger Koeppel, editor 
in chief of the German newspaper Die Welt, claiming that his decision to 
republish the Danish cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad that have caused such 
offense to Muslims was a free speech issue. “It’s at the very core of our 
culture that the most sacred things can be subjected to criticism, laughter 
and satire.” That is true, but it is not the only truth.

There is no contradiction between asserting the right of free speech and 
condemning those who use it to inflict gratuitous pain on others. 
Particularly when it is the powerful abusing the vulnerable.

Jyllands-Posten, which originally published the series of twelve cartoons 
about the Prophet over four months ago, has the largest circulation of any 
Danish newspaper. Denmark’s Muslim community, only 170,000 strong, is one of 
the most marginalized and beleaguered in Europe, and the governing coalition 
includes a large party that is explicitly anti-immigrant and implicitly 
anti-Muslim. The cartoons were neither clever nor funny, and two of them 
were blatantly offensive. One depicted the Prophet himself as a terrorist, 
his turban transformed into a fizzing bomb; the other showed him speaking to 
a ragged queue of suicide bombers at heaven’s gate saying, “Stop, stop, 
we’ve run out of virgins.” They deliberately implied that Islam is a 
terrorist religion, and Denmark’s Muslims quite reasonably demanded an 
apology. It was still a storm in a very small teacup — but then the usual 
suspects got to work.

The newspaper refused to apologize, and Denmark’s prime minister, Anders 
Fogh Rasmussen, sucked up to the anti-immigrant vote by refusing even to 
meet ambassadors from Muslim countries who wanted to protest about the 
cartoons. So a group of imams from the Danish Muslim organization Islamisk 
Trossamfund toured Middle Eastern in November and December with copies of 
the Jyllands-Posten cartoons, and included some others that were even more 
offensive.

It took a lot of time and effort to build this into a real confrontation, 
but the Norwegian Christian monthly Magazinet helpfully republished the 
cartoons in January, Saudi Arabia and Libya withdrew their ambassadors from 
Copenhagen, and indignation built steadily in Muslim chat-rooms and blogs on 
the Internet. By the end of January Danish flags were being burned and 
Danish goods boycotted in the Arab world, and both the Danish prime minister 
and the editor of Jyllands-Posten went into reverse, publicly apologizing 
for the offense that had been caused. But it was too late.

Various right-wing newspapers in Europe including Die Welt and France-Soir 
saw the Danish apologies as a failure to defend free speech, and republished 
the offending cartoons on their front pages. This gave radical Islamist 
fringe groups in European countries a pretext to stage angry demonstrations 
— the slogans at the London demo called for more terrorist bombs like those 
of last July and urged the faithful to “Butcher those who mock Islam” — and 
the confrontation finally achieved lift-off.

Late last week mobs attacked the European Union’s offices in the Gaza Strip 
and the building housing the Danish Embassy in Jakarta. Incensed by text 
messages saying that Danish right-wingers were planning to burn copies of 
the Qur’an (though they didn’t, in the end), angry Muslims burned the Danish 
and Norwegian embassies in Syria and the Danish Consulate in Lebanon during 
the weekend. The idiots, the ideologues and the fanatics on both sides have 
the bit between their teeth now, and it will take some time for the fury to 
burn out. But it is important to remember that most people have not lost 
their heads.

Inayat Banglawala, spokesman for the Muslim Council of Britain, said of the 
demonstrators who had urged more bomb attacks in Britain: “It is time the 
police acted, but in a way so as not to make them martyrs of the Prophet’s 
cause, which is what they want, but as criminals. Ordinary Muslims are fed 
up with them.” The 57-nation Organization of the Islamic Conference warned 
that “Overreactions surpassing the limits of peaceful democratic acts...are 
dangerous and detrimental to the efforts to defend the legitimate case of 
the Muslim world.”

Similarly on the Western side — you can’t really say Christian any more, 
except for the United States and maybe Poland — the great majority of 
newspapers did not publish the cartoons. In Britain, in Poland, in Russia, 
in Canada and (with one exception) in the United States, none did. It is not 
self-censorship to refuse to publish these abusive images that link Muslims 
with terrorism; it is simply common courtesy.

It does not mean that no Western cartoonist may ever use the Prophet again 
(though they will doubtless be more cautious about the context in future). 
The ban on images of the Prophet is a Muslim tradition, not a Western one. 
But we live in a joined-up world where everybody can see everybody else all 
the time, and being polite to the neighbors is a social obligation. 
Jyllands-Posten and its emulators were very stupid and very rude.

http://www.arabnews.com/?page=7&section=0&article=77429&d=7&m=2&y=2006




Post message: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subscribe   :  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Unsubscribe :  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
List owner  :  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/ 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 


Kirim email ke