http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2010/09/15/indonesia-not-suffering-dutch-disease.html

Indonesia is not suffering from the Dutch disease
HS Dillon, Jakarta | Wed, 09/15/2010 10:21 AM | Opinion 


A comprehensive strategic assessment of Indonesia's prospects for growth, 
equity and democratic governance, presented to selected constituents by a group 
of foreign scholars has become the talk of the town. The sobering diagnosis is 
welcome, although their standard prescriptions fall short of what is actually 
required. 

Recent events provide additional proof that although most of civil society is 
moving forward, the 
politicians, businessmen and bureaucrats are still deeply rooted in the past. 

Improper sequencing, poor governance and weak commitment have all contributed 
to the flagrant injustice, both in the case of institutionalized corruption and 
gross violation of human rights. 

The Asian crisis evidently did not produce any "catastrophic learning 
experience", as the elite, in fact, received twin bonuses: high interest rates 
for the rupiah and sharp appreciation of their American currency hoards. 

Decentralization, designed to enhance the quality of public services by 
bringing the locus of policy making closer to the constituents, turned into an 
overreaction against decades of Jakarta centralization.

In fact, reformasi was short-lived: impunity in the personae of Soeharto 
stalwarts and cronies finding refuge in either the old or newly established 
political parties, brought state-recapture on its heels. 

Thanks to the IMF and World Bank's ill advice, the rent-seeking crony 
capitalists walked away unscathed, leaving the poor holding the bag. 

Hence, it does not come as a surprise that all the subsequently founded 
"democratic" institutions actually had the same old authoritarian underlying 
values.  

The hue and cry raised by the enactment of the ASEAN China Free Trade Agreement 
(ACFTA) is one example of the glaring evidence that there has been no 
meaningful transformation toward a more competitive Indonesia. 

Thus, ridding the country of the identified institutional legacy will require a 
quality of commitment across the board, which has yet to appear on the horizon. 

The framework for further research being proposed should preferably take on 
board the uncomfortable truth that impoverishment continues apace even while 
the global elite keep propounding sustainable development. 

The sense of deprivation, as distress-push propels millions of semi-illiterates 
toward servitude in both urban centers and abroad, presents a fertile ground 
for the rise of a well-orchestrated campaign advocating fundamental 
pan-territorial religious beliefs. 

Now that the freedom of information and technological innovation bring images 
of the glamorous lifestyles of the elite to the hovels of the millions of poor, 
one can hardly expect citizenship to still have much relevance. 

The huge concentration of wealth amassed under the authoritarian regime had 
already become a source of major concern for president Soeharto himself, hence 
his convening of all crony conglomerates in his Tapos rural retreat.  

Seeing the Indonesian strongman being thwarted in his bid to effect a more 
sustainable distribution of wealth and income by the very rentiers he had 
created, was a traumatic experience for the government. 

It is an attestation to the formidable strength of the rent-seekers that all 
coming after him have shied away from squarely addressing both threats, leaving 
the Republic in a much more fragile state than one might like to believe.

Thus, instead of the touted reformasi, what we are witnessing instead is more 
of a prolonged deformasi, with roving bandits in control of deformed 
institutions. 

The political parties, which have actually been performing more as fan clubs 
than champions of substantive democracy, would appear to be major impediments 
to a more egalitarian and democratic 
Indonesia. 


"Reformasi was short-lived: impunity in the personae of Soeharto stalwarts and 
cronies finding refuge in either the old or newly established political 
parties."

A decade of muddling on has shown that entrenched interests at the heart of the 
state have managed to further strengthen their hold. 

The July 2010 op-ed "Ekspor Primitif" in the leading daily Kompas by Chatib 
Basri Ph.D., one of Indonesia's foremost economists, shows that the majority of 
businesses masquerading as "entrepreneurs" are still ensconced in their 
comfortable old business models. 

No, Indonesia is not suffering from the Dutch disease; it is being plagued by 
the "parasitic crony 
malady" with "easy rents driving innovation out". 

When you can thunder down Sudirman in a Hummer by trading commodities, why 
industrialize? Abandon hope, all ye dreaming of dislodging such powerful 
rent-seekers through moral suasion alone. 

 It is high time, therefore, to realize that we are fellow travelers on the 
spaceship Earth and rethink our development path. 

If we desire a more equitable and thriving civilization, we need to adopt a 
more sustainable development paradigm, with strategies and policies implemented 
in proper sequence. 

Through equal discourse with the people, we could plan our population properly, 
provide adequate food and nutrition, prepare health services that reach out and 
are affordable, propagate education that addresses local needs, and design 
institutions and infrastructure to actuate seamless economies.  

In short, growth through equity, wherein assets provided along with the World 
Bank prescribed access and income, could bestow such a strong voice upon the 
marginalized that governance - through constant rebalancing of the market, 
state and society - would become sustainable.

The envisaged "institutional transformation" entails battling in the trenches. 
To succeed, ownership of such a transformation needs to be well received by all 
components of contemporary Indonesian society. With parliament engrossed in 
securing creature comforts, it no longer is a question of political will on the 
part of President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono. 

The single major constraint is making the hodgepodge Cabinet and motley crew of 
both national and regional politicians actually respond to the needs of the 
people. 

It has become more a matter of strengthening the President's political capacity 
to convince our countrymen that the democratic path taken will deliver 
widespread prosperity to them and their future 
generations.


The writer was executive director of the Partnership for Governance Reform in 
Indonesia, 2004-2006.






[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke