http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2010\09\15\story_15-9-2010_pg3_3

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

WASHINGTON DIARY: Feudal-mullah alliance -Dr Manzur Ejaz



 The combination of rising mullah shahi and feudalism has produced the most 
corrupt and inhumane systems in human history. From mediaeval Europe to India 
to modern Pakistan, the feudal-clergy alliance - in most cases the clergy was 
the feudal - has devastated social development

The last time I checked the history books, it was clear to me that the British 
gave lands to our feudals. I had to check it again during the last week and I 
did not find anything contrary to my previous assessment. The cause for 
doubting my own recollection of history was due to an e-mail response to one of 
my articles from a reader.

The reader had serious problems with my emphasis on abolishing feudalism and 
enforcing a strict land reforms programme. The reader asserted that the land 
was given to the feudal class by God and that land reforms were akin to 
negating religion and the will of the Creator. The reader had suggested that we 
should plead to the rich to be kind to the poor and not indulge in methods 
negating the essence of our religion.

There is nothing new about this reader's critique. Such arguments were common 
in pre-industrial Europe where the Catholic Church was part of the ruling 
classes in exploiting the poor serfs. The fundamental thrust of Martin Luther's 
revolution was to free the masses of the feudal church's tyranny and translate 
the Bible into the German language, something that was absolutely prohibited: 
the Bible could be written in Latin only, understood by the clergy and not by 
common citizens. The Church of Rome wanted to hang Martin Luther for 
translating the Bible into German, but he was saved by the German rulers' 
adamant opposition.

The evolution of feudalism in India was no different from the one in Europe. Dr 
Ram Sharan Sharma has proved, taking pains in noting historical details, that 
feudalism in India was incubated by the rulers' grant of land to Brahmans and 
mandirs (temples). It was a bit later when those land grants were awarded for 
military services. Therefore, the earliest feudals were the clergy and the 
warriors. The Indian clergy's monopoly of Sanskrit as the only language of 
religious scriptures was just like Latin of the Catholic Church not being 
understood by common folks in Europe.

During Muslim rule in India, specifically during the Mughal era, the jagirdar 
(feudal) was a temporary post, besides permanent land grants to shrines and 
religious establishments. Usually, a dignitary was assigned a large tract 
comprising several villages for a certain period but transferred to another 
area after that time. A jagirdar of Punjab could have been transferred to 
Bengal after two years. Consequently, the jagirdars had no permanent stakes in 
an area and were bent on skimming off from the people as much as they could 
because of their uncertain future. However, the landed aristocracy created 
through land grants to shrines and religious establishments was perpetual.

The British continued the practice with some fundamental changes. They expanded 
the land grants to shrines of all kinds and that is why we see so many feudals 
bearing the last name of Shah, Makhdoom, etc. The British also made large 
grants to Jat and Rajput leading families like the Tiwanas, Noons and Daultanas 
for providing crucial services to the British Raj. In short, the feudals, 
religious or otherwise, were granted land for aiding the colonialists.

The land grants were always given by the rulers whether they were Hindus, 
Muslims or the British. How did it then become the recipients' God-given right? 
I am sure that rulers, corrupt, cruel or otherwise, could not be elevated to 
the status of God as our reader believes. Therefore, if the rulers of today 
abolish feudalism, they will just be reversing the decisions of earlier rulers 
and not of God.

In the early days of Islam, land holdings were not a big issue because there 
were no big tracts of agricultural land in Saudi Arabia. However, the issue 
became divisive when the Muslims conquered the fertile lands of Syria, Iraq and 
Egypt. The conquering generals wanted possession of the newly fertile conquered 
lands but the second caliph, Hazrat Umar, did not permit this. Many believe 
that he was martyred by the group of generals whose possession of lands he was 
opposing. It is noteworthy that the third caliph, Hazrat Usman, granted the 
right of land possession immediately after being installed.

One thing is clear: the nexus between feudalism and the religious 
establishment, clergy or spiritualists, is the basis of the rise of feudalism. 
Therefore, our reader's assertion reflects the traditionalist, mullah shahi 
view. Sufi poets like Sultan Bahu, Bulleh Shah and Waris Shah were not only 
attacking the mullah shahi's religious doctrine but also their cooperation with 
the feudal. Waris Shah was much clearer and straight in taking the corrupt 
religious establishment to task for their servitude to the feudal. Sometimes, 
it feels that we are still living in the 18th century where mullah shahi is 
doing the same job for the feudal. It does not come as a surprise that the 
feudal and mullah/jihadi do not bother each other.

The combination of rising mullah shahi and feudalism has produced the most 
corrupt and inhumane systems in human history. From mediaeval Europe to India 
to modern Pakistan, the feudal-clergy alliance - in most cases the clergy was 
the feudal - has devastated social development. Feudalism may be defended on 
economic grounds - fractionalisation of land may lead to a less productive 
system - but it cannot be defended on a political and social basis.

The grip of the narrow-minded and backward feudal class does not allow the 
development of a modern state. The US, Europe and other industrial nations may 
spend billions of dollars to modernise the Pakistani state but it is not going 
to happen unless feudalism is abolished. The US should know better that Japan 
and South Korea developed after the end of feudalism. The new generation of 
Americans, wedded to 'Reaganism', has no clue about the post-World War II 
ideologies that prompted the land reforms in Japan and South Korea. Therefore, 
the movement for ending feudalism has to come from within the country. Unless 
feudalism is abolished, neither democratic governments nor military rule can 
modernise the state.

Pleading to the rich to be kind to the poor has never happened in history. It 
always takes a bloody revolution to distribute wealth. Pakistan is not going to 
be any different from other countries.

The writer can be reached at [email protected]









[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke