Menurut TV Aljazeerah beberapa waktu lalu diberitakan bahwa di kelder KBRI di 
Beirut ditampung 130 TKW yang lari dari majilan mereka, ada yang diperkosa, 
disika dan juga tidak bayar gaji. Tetapi karena Indonesia jongkok-jongkok 
kepada orang Arab dan oleh karena itu pemerintah Indonesia tidak protes.

  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Jusfiq 
  To: [email protected] 
  Sent: Thursday, September 16, 2010 11:24 AM
  Subject: [proletar] Aljazeera: Overworked and unpaid, an increasingly common 
occurrence for foreign


    


  Waiting for justice
  The cases of abused migrant domestic workers in Lebanon can take years to get 
to court.
  Nadim Houry Last Modified: 16 Sep 2010 09:06 GMT

  Overworked and unpaid, an increasingly common occurrence for foreign domestic 
workers [AFP]

  "Amelia," a Filipina domestic worker who sought shelter at her embassy in 
Beirut earlier this year, had one wish: "I just want to get my money [unpaid 
wages] and to go back to the Philippines." Her employer had savagely beaten her 
with a stick - as photos taken by the forensic doctor clearly showed - and 
allegedly owed her $3,800 in unpaid wages. But while Amelia's wishes were 
clear, her circumstances were complicated - a situation she shared with many 
other migrant domestic workers in Lebanon and elsewhere in the Middle East.

  Under Lebanon's kafeel (sponsorship) system, she lost her legal residency as 
soon as she left her abusive employer. She was consequently confined to her 
embassy - which was already overcrowded with other domestic workers who had 
fled similar situations. It would probably take at least two years for her to 
seek her back wages in court. And she faced an additional hurdle: Her employer 
held her identity papers and had filed a theft claim against her - a claim she 
vehemently denied and which her embassy appointed lawyer believed her employers 
filed to pressure her into dropping her claims.

  I met Amelia during my research for Human Rights Watch into the recourse 
available to domestic workers against abusive employers in Lebanon. We 
interviewed abused domestic workers in shelters, as well as the lawyers and 
diplomats who assisted them, and reviewed 114 judicial decisions affecting 
domestic workers.

  "When we tell a worker the legal process will take years and she will have to 
stay here, she immediately backs away."

  A labour attaché at one of the embassies

  For years, we had documented the abuses these workers suffered. Now we wanted 
to know how the stories ended for these young women who came from the 
Philippines, Sri Lanka, Ethiopia, Nepal, and Bangladesh, to live and work in 
houses of complete strangers. Many had positive experiences. But what happened 
to those with valid complaints against their employers? What recourse did they 
have if an employer did not pay the wages owed? Did Lebanon's courts punish 
employers who committed crimes against these workers?

  Human Rights Watch's report, published this week, shows a justice system with 
inaccessible complaint mechanisms, lengthy judicial procedures, and restrictive 
visa policies that dissuade many workers from filing or pursuing complaints 
against their employers. Daunted, many of the workers settled for a ticket 
home, hoping to end their nightmare.

  A labour attaché at one of the embassies said: "When we tell a worker the 
legal process will take years and she will have to stay here, she immediately 
backs away." In our sample, criminal cases by workers against employers took an 
average of 24 months to resolve. Complaints for unpaid wages took between 21 
and 54 months. Even simplified complaints brought before labour courts took 32 
months on average.

  When domestic workers did file complaints, the police and judicial 
authorities regularly failed to treat certain abuses as crimes. We did not find 
a single example among the 114 cases we reviewed in which an employer faced 
charges for locking a worker inside a home, confiscating the worker's passport, 
or denying the person food, although we know from our fieldwork that these 
violations of the law are commonplace. This was disappointing, but not 
particularly surprising, given that police officers and prosecutors are often 
themselves employers of domestic workers and consider it "normal" to hold a 
worker's passport or to lock her inside the house to ensure that she does not 
"run away".

  Even cases of physical violence against migrant domestic workers often failed 
to garner sufficient attention from police and prosecutors. In a 2005 case, the 
police waited 21 days to begin investigating a complaint that an employer was 
beating a domestic worker. The most severe sentence that a court has imposed on 
an employer for beating a domestic worker was a one-month prison term, handed 
down last June 26. While such a ruling shows the positive role that the 
judiciary can play, it remains an exception: Employers have been sentenced to 
prison in only a handful of beating cases. 

  If the Lebanese authorities are committed to improving the treatment of 
domestic workers - and the Lebanese ministers of interior and labour say they 
are - then they need to train law enforcement officials and labour inspectors 
to identify and prosecute violations against domestic workers. When an employer 
locks a domestic worker in the house or beats the worker up, that is a crime, 
and the authorities need to prosecute this behaviour. To find these violations, 
the police and labour inspectors need to conduct home inspections - even if 
this displeases Lebanese employers. Finally, Lebanon's parliament needs to 
reform the sponsorship system so that a worker's legal residency is no longer 
tied to the will of an individual employer.

  These reforms may not be popular, given widely held views by employers that 
no one should interfere with what happens inside their homes. But to continue 
to turn a blind eye to these violations is to be complicit in the ongoing 
abuses. As for Amelia, she left Lebanon before her case concluded and is still 
waiting for her wages.

  Nadim Houry is the director of the Beirut office at Human Rights Watch.



  





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke