http://arabnews.com/opinion/columns/article139178.ece

By JOHN V. WHITBECK | ARAB NEWS 
Two states and one Holy Land 

As the Israeli-Palestinian "peace process" struggles to inch forward again in 
an atmosphere of profound pessimism bordering on hopelessness, what is most 
sadly missing is any compelling vision of how a Holy Land at peace could be 
structured so as to enhance not only the physical security of Israelis and the 
human dignity of Palestinians but also the future quality of day-to-day life 
for both peoples.

<b>(EDITOR'S NOTE: On Sept. 5, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu urged 
a new approach to issues that have defied resolution in past 
Israeli-Palestinian negotiations, telling reporters that, for the new round of 
negotiations to succeed, "we will have to learn the lessons of 17 years of 
experience from negotiations and to think creatively - what's called 'outside 
the box.'" Between 1988 and 2000, international lawyer John Whitbeck's "Two 
States, One Holy Land" framework for peace was published 40 times, in various 
lengths and in the Arabic, Dutch, English, French, German and Hebrew languages. 
In response to Netanyahu's call for creative, "outside the box" thinking and in 
the hope stimulating such thinking, we are publishing below an updated version 
of Whitbeck's framework for a two-state solution which, rather than separating 
Israelis and Palestinians, would bring them together in "a new society of 
peaceful coexistence, mutual respect and human dignity.")</b>



The Declaration of Principles so optimistically signed on the White House lawn 
in September 1993 proclaimed as its goal a "historic reconciliation" between 
the two peoples. Today, even optimists seem to hope only for a definitive 
separation of the two peoples behind high walls and fences.

Can Israelis and Palestinians really do no better than this? Might it not still 
be possible to blend the practical and psychological preferences of both 
peoples for a two-state solution with some of the best aspects of a humane 
one-state solution to produce a vision of a possible future so bright and 
appealing that both Israelis and Palestinians would be inspired to act on their 
hopes and dreams rather than their memories and fears and to seize this future 
together and make it a reality?

Sharing the Holy Land is not a zero-sum game in which any development 
advantageous to one side must be disadvantageous to the other. One can envisage 
a society in which, by separating political and voting rights from economic, 
social and residential rights in a negotiated settlement, both the legitimate 
national aspirations of Palestinians and the legitimate security interests of 
Israelis could be simultaneously satisfied.

The Holy Land could be a two-state "confederation", a single economic and 
social unit encompassing two sovereign states and one Holy City. Jerusalem 
could be an Israeli-Palestinian "condominium", an open city forming an 
undivided part of both states, being the capital of both states and being 
administered by local district councils and an umbrella municipal council.

All current residents of the Holy Land could be given the choice of Israeli or 
Palestinian citizenship, thus determining which state's passport they would 
carry and in which state's national elections they would vote. All citizens of 
either state could vote in municipal elections where they actually live, a 
matter of particular relevance to current Palestinian citizens of Israel opting 
for Palestinian citizenship and to Israeli settlers choosing to continue to 
live in Palestine while maintaining their Israeli citizenship. Each state could 
have its own "law of return" conferring citizenship and residential rights 
within that state on persons not currently resident in the Holy Land.

Borders would have to be drawn on maps but would not have to exist on the 
ground. The free, non-discriminatory movement of people and goods within the 
Holy Land could be a fundamental principle subject only to one major exception: 
To ensure that each state would always maintain its national character, the 
right to residence in each Holy Land state could be limited to that state's 
citizens, to citizens of the other state residing there on an agreed date and 
to their descendants. (In this way, deeply felt principles could be maintained. 
Israelis could have the right to live in all of Eretz Israel - but not all 
Israelis in all of Eretz Israel. Similarly, Palestinians could have the right 
to live in all of historical Palestine - but not all Palestinians in all of 
historical Palestine.) A common currency (perhaps printed in Hebrew on one side 
and Arabic on the other) could be issued by a common central bank.

To ease Israeli security concerns, the Palestinian state could be fully 
demilitarized, with no one other than Palestinian police allowed to bear arms 
within its territory. As an essential counterpart to the absence of border 
controls within the Holy Land, Israel could conduct immigration controls for 
entry into Israel, at the same time that Palestine conducts immigration 
controls for entry into Palestine, at the frontiers of the Palestinian state 
with Egypt and Jordan, with any non-Palestinian visitors restricted to the 
Palestinian state by the Israeli authorities facing penalties if found in 
Israel. The settlement agreement could be guaranteed by the United Nations and 
relevant states, with international tribunals to arbitrate disputes regarding 
compliance with its terms.

The status of Jerusalem poses the toughest problem for any settlement plan, 
causing many to assume, for this reason alone, that no settlement acceptable to 
both sides can ever be reached. When the UN General Assembly adopted Resolution 
181 in 1947, it addressed the problem by suggesting an international status for 
Jerusalem, with neither the Jewish state nor the Arab state to have sovereignty 
over the city. Yet joint undivided sovereignty, while rare, is not without 
precedent.

Chandigarh is the joint undivided capital of two Indian states. For half a 
century, Sudan was a condominium of Britain and Egypt, officially named 
"Anglo-Egyptian Sudan". For more than 70 years, the Pacific Islands state of 
Vanuatu (formerly the New Hebrides Condominium) was under the joint undivided 
sovereignty of Britain and France. For more than 700 years, until a 1993 
constitutional revision, the Principality of Andorra was under the joint 
undivided sovereignty of French and Spanish "coprinces". In March 1999, the 
arbitrator appointed by the International Court of Justice ruled that the 
contested Bosnian municipality of Brcko should be a condominium shared by 
Bosnia's Serb Republic and its Muslim-Croat Federation.

As a joint capital, Jerusalem could have Israeli government offices principally 
in its western sector, Palestinian government offices principally in its 
eastern sector and municipal offices in both.

A system of districts or French-style arrondissements could bring municipal 
government closer to the different communities in the city (including the 
ultra-Orthodox Jewish community), with local district councils dealing with all 
matters best dealt with locally and an umbrella municipal council dealing only 
with those matters requiring citywide coordination. To the extent that either 
state wished to control people or goods passing into it from the other state, 
this could be done at the points of exit from, rather than the points of entry 
to, Jerusalem. In a context of peace, particularly one coupled with economic 
union, the need for such controls would be minimal.

In a sense, Jerusalem can be viewed as a cake that could be sliced either 
vertically or horizontally. Either way, both Israelis and Palestinians would 
get a share of the cake, but, while many Israelis could never voluntarily 
swallow a vertical slice, they might just be able to swallow a horizontal 
slice. Indeed, by doing so, Israel would finally achieve international 
recognition of Jerusalem as its capital. Embassies to Israel, all of which are 
currently located in Tel Aviv in a reflection of the nonrecognition by the 
international community of Israel's claim to sovereignty over Jerusalem, could 
be expected to move there.

Jerusalem is both a municipality on the ground and a symbol in hearts and 
minds. Undivided but shared in this way, Jerusalem could be a symbol of 
reconciliation and hope for Jews, Muslims, Christians and the world as a whole. 
It would be so even if the "condominium" principle of joint undivided 
sovereignty were formally applied only to the contested heart of Jerusalem, 
notably the Old City and the Mount of Olives, with sovereignty over the other 
parts of an open city being assigned to one or the other of the two states.

Such a framework would address in ways advantageous to both sides three of the 
principal practical problems on the road to peace - Jerusalem (through joint 
sovereignty over an undivided city), settlers (through a separation of 
citizenship rights from residential rights in a regime of free access to the 
entire Holy Land for all citizens of both states under which no one would be 
compelled to move) and borders (through a structure of relations between the 
two states so open and nonthreatening that the precise placement of borders 
would no longer be such a contentious issue and the internationally recognized 
pre-1967 borders - subject only to the expanded borders of Jerusalem, under 
joint sovereignty - might well be acceptable to most Israelis, as they would 
certainly be to most Palestinians).

For Jewish Israelis, the rapidly approaching inevitability of living in a state 
with either a majority of Arab voters or an inescapable resemblance to pre-1990 
South Africa and worldwide pariah status would be replaced by the assurance of 
living in a democratic state with fewer Arab voters than today. Israel's 
security would be enhanced by assuaging, rather than continuing to aggravate, 
the Palestinians' grievances and the hatred throughout the Arab and Muslim 
worlds based upon the perpetuation of those grievances. By escaping from the 
role (so tragic in light of Jewish history) of oppressors and enforcers of 
injustice, Israel would save its soul and its dreams.

For all Palestinians, human dignity would be restored. They would cease to be a 
people treated (and not only by Israelis) as uniquely unworthy of basic human 
rights. For those in exile, an internationally accepted Palestinian 
citizenship, a Palestinian passport and a right to return to all of pre-1948 
Palestine, if only to visit, would have enormous significance.

Furthermore, if the Palestinians themselves accepted a settlement, all Arab 
states would establish normal diplomatic and commercial relations with Israel, 
as has been made clear in the Arab Peace Initiative of 2002, which remains on 
the table, waiting to be seized by Israel. If a Palestinian flag were 
peacefully raised over Palestinian government offices in Jerusalem, few Arab or 
Muslim eyes would still see Israel through a veil of hatred. The immovable 
obstacle to a lasting region-wide peace would have been removed.

While implementation of such a framework for peace would be relatively simple 
(far more so than traditional "two-state solutions" premised on the separation 
of Israelis and Palestinians), its acceptance would require a moral, spiritual 
and psychological transformation from both Israelis and Palestinians. Yet, 
given the decades of hatred, bitterness and distrust, aggravated by the past 17 
years of a failed and seemingly perpetual "peace process", any settlement would 
require such a transformation.

Precisely because such a transformation would be so difficult, it is far more 
likely to be achieved if both peoples can be inspired by a truly compelling 
vision of a new society of peaceful coexistence, mutual respect and human 
dignity, in which both peoples are winners, than if they are left to 
contemplate painful programs for a new partition and an angry separation in 
which both peoples must regard themselves, to a considerable degree, as 
admitting defeat.

Israelis, Palestinians and the true friends of both must now resist the 
temptation to despair, raise their sights and pursue a compelling vision of a 
society so much better than the status quo that both Israelis and Palestinians 
are inspired to accept in their hearts and minds that peace is both desirable 
and attainable, that the Holy Land can be shared, that a winner-take-all 
approach produces only losers, that both Israelis and Palestinians must be 
winners or both will continue to be losers and that there is a common 
destination at which both peoples would be satisfied to arrive and to live 
together. (Concluded)



-  John V. Whitbeck has advised the Palestinian negotiating team in 
negotiations with Israel. This framework for peace was the subject of a 
three-day conference of 24 prominent Israelis and Palestinians, including four 
Knesset members, held in Cairo in November 1993 under the sponsorship of The 
Middle East Institute (Washington).








[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke