http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/opinion/the-christmas-question-and-other-distractions-wed-do-well-to-ignore/413143

The Christmas Question, and Other Distractions We'd Do Well to Ignore
Bramantyo Prijosusilo | December 22, 2010



An Arab man dressed up as Santa Claus hands out Christmas trees donated by the 
Jerusalem municipality to Jerusalem citizens. How Muslims handle Christmas is a 
thorny issue. EPA Photo 



As we approach Christmas and the New Year, some Muslim factions are once again 
wasting their time on the dead debate on whether it is permissible for Muslims 
to wish others a "Merry Christmas." Fundamentalists say Christmas greetings 
constitute a grave sin, as the message is tacitly agreeing with the notion that 
God has a son. 

On the other hand, Sofjan Siregar, a senior lecturer based in the Netherlands, 
told a gathering organized by the Association of Indonesian Muslim 
Intellectuals (ICMI) recently at a mosque in Rotterdam that there was no 
explicit prohibition of the holiday greeting in either the Koran or in the 
Hadith (the words and deeds of Prophet Muhammad). Sofjan said because a 
greeting of this nature was not part of religious ritual, there was no sin in 
participating in it. Needless to say, within hours of his comments being 
reported, radical Web sites and forums had begun to vilify him for his opinion. 

The fact that this dead donkey is beaten again every year indicates that there 
are sections of the Muslim community here that are bent on stirring up a furor 
to ruin interreligious relations in our pluralistic society. Throughout the 
year, we have witnessed incidents in which fundamentalist groups attacked or 
harassed Christians and Ahmadiyah followers. Unreported by most news services 
but evident in online discussion forums, Web sites and magazines, hard-liners 
also have their sights set on Javanese Muslims, Shiite Muslims, liberal 
Muslims, followers of the late President Gus Dur and basically anyone not part 
of their group or following their ideology. 

We have also seen how groups like the notoriously violent Islamic Defenders 
Front (FPI) have been given extra clout by a friendly national chief of police. 
Local administrations like Aceh have made headlines worldwide for human rights 
violations disguised as Shariah law enforcement, but less dramatic cases of 
questionable ethics, like the Bogor municipal government spending funds from 
its development budget on pocket money for civil servants on hajj, and games of 
chance where the winners are paid to go on the pilgrimage, have passed more or 
less unnoticed. 

The latest of these cases is the tug-of-war between the congregation of the 
Indonesian Christian Church of Taman Yasmin, Bogor, and the municipal 
government backed by Islamist groups, in which a dispute over permission to 
build a church sees it sealed up and reopened on a regular basis. The most 
ironic case, though, is probably the statement from ex-convict Rizieq Shihab, 
the leader of the FPI, who declared that Christians should be allowed to 
celebrate Christmas in peace (providing they behave). 

Considering that the administration of President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has 
the strongest mandate that any government has ever had in this country, the 
fact that his government not only tolerates but actually encourages groups and 
activities that are so obviously at odds with Pancasila and the Constitution is 
extremely curious. While Yudhoyono is the only directly elected president that 
we have ever had, his leadership has also seen the most persecution of 
minorities by religious thugs. Could it be that their existence has a strategic 
value for his survival at the top? 

If sociologist Dr. Zastrow Al Ngatawi's findings in his study of the FPI a few 
years back are true, then probably there is some factual basis behind the 
analysis that sees these organizations as pawns in the power plays. Zastrow 
concluded that such groups are actually nurtured by the powers that be to act 
as attack dogs when needed in order to divert attention from whatever is foul 
upstairs, to create horizontal conflict in order to avoid vertical conflict, 
and to allow corruption and human rights abuses by the elite to pass unnoticed. 

But why, one is compelled to ask, would a government with an unprecedented 
mandate and a clean and democratic image need such an underhand ploy if a ploy 
it is? If there's truth to sociologist and corruption expert George Junus 
Aditjondro's book on corruption in the highest office in this country, then the 
theory about maintaining horizontal conflicts to safeguard the interests of the 
elite might be valid. Come to think of it, what has happened to all the money 
that was stolen from Bank Century? How come the legislature's special 
commission set up to reveal the truth about the scandal only managed to make 
the truth even more opaque? If George's book was nothing but defamation, as his 
critics claim, why hasn't he been successfully prosecuted? 

Also, one might ask, why has the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) 
systematically and consistently been weakened? Why has there been no closure 
for the Lapindo mud volcano drilling catastrophe? Why has a private amateur 
adult video dominated the news for so long? Why is the special status of 
Yogyakarta being made an issue right now when the region is still recovering 
from Merapi's recent explosions? What are the actual priorities of this 
government, if it has any? 

Whatever the reasons for these distractions, the tolerance of and support for 
groups that use religion - namely Islam - to violate the human rights of 
citizens in this country should be halted. Even if the government tacitly 
supports these groups, patriotic citizens should not, because the damage that 
hard-liners inflict on the foundations of our state will last much longer than 
the maximum term that a president can stay in power. 

It is high time for ordinary citizens of all religions to stand up against 
those who use Islam to ignite conflicts in society, whatever their motives are. 
It is blasphemy to claim to be an adherent of Islam while attacking followers 
of other faiths, spreading hatred and destruction. Citizens who support 
Pancasila and the Constitution should sue these blasphemers and withdraw 
support from this government for encouraging them. 

  

Bramantyo Prijosusilo is an artist, poet and organic farmer in Ngawi, East Java.













[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke