http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2010\12\31\story_31-12-2010_pg3_6

Friday, December 31, 2010

VIEW: Rape shield laws -Saroop Ijaz

 Rape shield laws are statutes or court rules that limit the introduction of 
evidence about a victim's character history, reputation or past conduct during 
a rape trial. One ostensible objective of these laws is to help ensure that 
rape victims are treated with fairness, dignity and respect during a criminal 
trial



"There is one custom amongst these people which is wholly shameful: every woman 
who is native of the country must once in her life go and sit in the temple of 
Mylitta and there give herself to a strange man....Once a woman has taken her 
seat, she is not allowed to go home until a man has thrown her a silver coin 
into her lap and taken her outside to lie with her. As he throws the coin, the 
man has to say, 'In the name of the goddess Mylitta'...When she has lain with 
him, her duty to the goddess is discharged and she may go home" (Herodotus, 
Histories; 1.199).

A few days ago in Karachi, a horrific though not uncommon incident took place 
that shakes the very moral fabric of our society. A woman was allegedly 
abducted, gang-raped and later dumped in a posh locality of the city by 
unidentified men. The alleged perpetrators are being apprehended and the case 
is under investigation. It is premature to comment on the outcome of the 
investigation. Yet the alleged incident and, equally significantly, the 
response to it raise broader fundamental questions regarding the kind of 
society that we have become.

The initial statements made by the police authorities were understandably vague 
as they were made prior to a detailed investigation. However, there were 
insinuations made regarding the character, manner of dressing, etc, of the 
survivor by the police, media personnel and politicians, which are a cause for 
greater alarm. Rape, historically, was considered an instrument for the moral 
condemnation of women who have not led sexually chaste lives. The law 
traditionally mandated that the sexual history of a woman who alleged that she 
was raped was relevant to the truth of her allegation. A chaste woman was 
considered more likely to have resisted the unwelcome advances and to have 
lodged a legitimate claim of rape. The absurdity of this argument is intuitive, 
yet our societal handling of rape cases seems to betray this obvious 
understanding.

According to the Aurat Foundation, 483 cases of rape/gang-rape in Pakistan (377 
in Punjab; 95 in Sindh; four in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa; four in Balochistan; three 
in Islamabad) were reported in the first half of 2010. Given the stigma 
attached with reporting a rape claim and enduring the ordeal of a public trial, 
it is safe to assume that the actual incidence of rape is likely to be much 
higher than the reported figures. These statistics paint a ghastly picture. The 
victims of rape in a country like ours suffer more than merely the trauma 
stemming from the incident, both physically and psychologically. They and their 
families also suffer from the effects of intimidation, ridicule, rude 
speculations and overall diminished social status. The prospect of being 
tormented in a police station and/or a courtroom is enough to deter many women 
from bringing in rape claims.

In the 1970s, 'rape shield laws' emerged in the jurisprudence of the US and 
subsequently Europe with the objective of curtailing the excesses of the 
chastity requirement. Legislators in those jurisdictions concluded that it was 
illogical to assume that the complainant consented to intercourse with the 
accused, or was more likely to lie under oath, simply because of her past 
character history, profession or the manner in which she chooses to dress. This 
logic eludes not only our legislators but society as a whole.

Rape shield laws are statutes or court rules that limit the introduction of 
evidence about a victim's character history, reputation or past conduct during 
a rape trial. Rape shield laws generally prohibit the introduction of opinion 
and reputation evidence about the character history of the victim. They also 
typically provide that evidence of specific prior conduct of the victim is 
presumed irrelevant unless it is direct evidence of the source of the incident. 
One ostensible objective of these laws is to help ensure that rape victims are 
treated with fairness, dignity and respect during a criminal trial by ensuring 
that the victim will not be subject to a public airing of her reputation, past 
conduct, and other irrelevant information. Rape shield laws were designed, in 
part, to make it more likely for victims to come forward. If rape victims have 
their entire character history revealed and examined in court as part of a rape 
prosecution, it is likely that such exposure will deter other victims from 
reporting rape. This is especially relevant for a society like ours having a 
misogynist legal and political system that seeks to exclude women at a systemic 
level. General Musharraf, once commenting on the Mukhtaran Mai case, observed 
that Pakistani women have come up with a particularly arduous scheme of 
obtaining foreign visas - by getting raped.

The reaction of our society, police, media and authorities to rape claims is 
geared towards discouraging rape victims (inadvertently in certain cases) to 
come forth and prosecute offenders. The legislators have to consider adopting a 
variant of the rape shield laws in Pakistan, if we aim to curtail the incidence 
of rape.

The writer is a lawyer and can be reached at [email protected]




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke