BBC News Africa

9 March 2011 Last updated at 17:26 GMT


Libya crisis: Options for intervention
Libyan rebel fighters amass ammunition near the town of Ras Lanuf, 8 March 2011

As Libya's crisis continues to worry world leaders, BBC diplomatic 
correspondent Jonathan Marcus looks at the options for intervention that might 
be considered, and the challenges and potential consequences of each.

Survival may be the main concern for Libya's embattled leader, Colonel Muammar 
Gaddafi, but in strategic terms his forces appear to have two main goals.

The first is to extend the area they control to the west and south of the 
capital Tripoli, in an effort to solidify their hold over this half of the 
country. This explains the fighting in and around Zawiya.

With rebel forces holding key cities in eastern Libya, Colonel Gaddafi's troops 
look set to try to push eastwards towards Ras Lanuf to see if they can "bite 
off" at least one more rebel-held town.

There is some discussion in military circles as to the Gaddafi loyalists' 
military capacities.
Map of Libya

For a start, how many of his troops are needed to maintain his hold on Tripoli 
itself? How many can he concentrate and deploy elsewhere?

Are his commanders able to mount effective combined arms operations using 
armour, infantry and air assets?

And are the forces that have remained loyal to Colonel Gaddafi really that 
committed to the regime or are they, in part, being induced by cash payments?

Might more of his forces go over to his opponents if the overall balance of 
power was significantly seen to change?

The balance of advantage seems to have shifted towards the Gaddafi loyalists in 
recent days.

However, over time, if the anti-Gaddafi forces can hold out in the east, and 
crucially, if they can gain some support in terms of training and equipment 
from outside, they may be able to mount offensive operations of their own.

For now though, quite apart from their lack of air power, Colonel Gaddafi's 
opponents also lack the strategic mobility, for example, to move heavy armour 
westwards to pose a threat to key coastal towns.

All these factors will be in the minds of Western governments, diplomats and 
military planners as they meet over the coming days to discuss the options 
available to them.

All options are being considered, we are told, so what might they include?

No-fly zone

This is the main "military option" being discussed at the moment. There should 
be clarity from the outset. Experts stress this is not some neutral measure but 
the thin end of the wedge of military intervention.

The bulk of the aircraft needed would presumably come from Nato, although there 
would clearly be a desire to involve others to demonstrate that this is not 
just one more "Western incursion" into the Middle East.

One regional grouping, the Gulf Co-operation Council, has already thrown its 
weight firmly behind a no-fly zone.
An F/A-18F Super Hornet launches during operations aboard the aircraft carrier 
USS Enterprise in the Red Sea (US Navy handout photo), 7 March 2011 Libya's 
rebel fighters want a no-fly zone to be enforced by the international community

Significant questions, though, still need to be answered.

Would a specific UN resolution be required to establish such a zone? Would 
Russia and China be willing to endorse this approach? And if not, would the 
support of regional players be sufficient for the US and its allies to go ahead 
anyway?

How would a no-fly zone be rolled out? Would it begin with air attacks against 
Colonel Gaddafi's anti-aircraft missiles and radar systems, as US Defence 
Secretary Robert Gates has suggested, or might these defences only be targeted 
if patrolling warplanes were themselves "illuminated" or engaged by Libyan 
defences?

Prediction: There are many advocating it and, equally, many arguing caution. It 
is the most likely of all the options to be implemented but it raises many 
questions in terms of effectiveness. And if it does not significantly change 
the dynamics on the ground, what then?
Direct air action

Rather than a protracted effort to constrain the Libyan Air Force by constant 
patrolling and interceptions where necessary, another approach might be to 
simply try and put it out of action by cratering runways or even destroying 
planes on the ground.

Prediction: Will not be at top of list - smacks of full-scale intervention.
No-drive zone

This is essentially a ground extension of the no-fly zone idea, a variant of 
which was employed against Saddam Hussein's Iraq.

Put simply, you designate lines beyond which armoured formations must not move 
or they will risk attack.

This, however, is much harder to enforce over a country the size of Libya and 
would require a different set of aircraft capable of mounting attacks against 
ground forces.

Prediction: As above, not top of list.
Arm and train

If a military stalemate ensues, Colonel Gaddafi's opponents are going to need 
outside training and support.

This does not necessarily have to come from the West. Egypt's military, for 
example, is highly capable and has a strong strategic interest in the events 
going on over its western border.

This, of course, presumes that there is sufficient time to mould the 
anti-Gaddafi elements into a coherent fighting force.

Prediction: Attractive in terms of being arms-length and about evening up the 
balance of forces. But will take time. Who would do it? What weaponry would be 
supplied? And where might that weaponry end up in the longer term? Again not at 
top of list but may well become a live issue if stalemate sets in and conflict 
continues.
Rebel fighters pray in front of a burning gas storage terminal during a battle 
on the road between Ras Lanuf and Bin Jawad, 9 March 2011 If the stalemate 
continues, foreign powers may consider training and arming Libyan rebels
Risks on all sides

Everything depends upon two fundamental questions:

What is it that the outside military actors - the UN, Nato, the US or whoever - 
want to achieve?

And secondly, how fragile do they believe Colonel Gaddafi's forces really are?

Is a no-fly zone really intended to change the course of fighting on the ground 
and if so, would it have this effect?

Many experts are sceptical, noting that up to now the pro-Gaddafi forces' use 
of air power has not yet been shown to be a decisive factor in the fighting.

Intervention of any kind carries risks. But standing by, especially as 
humanitarian concerns grow, has consequences too.

Perhaps the hope is that some demonstration of outside force might be 
sufficient to prompt further defections from Colonel Gaddafi's forces. But as 
experience shows, no-fly zones and more explicit offensive action tend to be 
closely linked.

Once you start at that thin end of the wedge, who knows what might happen next?




------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke