--------------------------------------------
On Mon, 4/7/14, Jukka K. Korpela <[email protected]> wrote:


 Undoubtedly it is fairly common, and we could present a good
 argument in favor of it: most country selection controls are
 faulty one way or another (e.g., missing new countries and
 displaying countries that have ceased to exist, or wrong
 names), and the quality might be improved, if they were
 based on native controls in browsers, updated frequently.

======================
I think the basic problem is that everyone's Boss has assumed dreams of 
incremental world domination.  This leads coders to include the missing and 
stop when the Boss does not see anything missing.  It is not a good way for 
Consultancies to work.  A Strategy Markup Language[1], Data Journalism[2], 
Linked Data ID Server[3], or a Cloud have to work in a different way.

One thing which considerably simplifies the task is to assume unidirectional 
data flow (either imports or exports). Also, the fine structure of imports in 
world trade is much more complex than that of exports.  The evidence is that 
"The Silk Road" between Asia and Europe worked so well because the two local 
naming Authorities on either end made the mid-route secure per force although 
for practical reasons did not bother with interoperability.

http://www.rustprivacy.org/faca/simTLD/

If this all sounds like browser/format wars and Social Networking privacy ills, 
it should, because the overarching logistics are the same.  Pity, really, the 
ability to launch a Crusade or summon up the Mongol Horde might lead to a much 
more sane debate about data privacy. 

I  originally named the scheme "The Silk Road" ... a week before a drug ring of 
the same name was busted.  My bad luck :)  The new name is simTLD (simulated 
Top Level Domain) is straightforward - Authority by circularly polarized 
coordinates. This is IEEE territory not W3C territory.

======================
 
 But I'm afraid the counterarguments are too strong.
 -- Yucca, http://www.cs.tut.fi/~jkorpela/

======================

I agree, this is way too ambitious for (every day use) HTML5 as it depends upon 
external standards for missing items.  The possible depends on your definition 
of "data analytics" not on communication with markup languages.

--Gannon

[1] http://stratml.hyperbase.com/stratml.html
[2] http://semanticommunity.info/
[3] http://id.loc.gov/

 
 
 

Reply via email to