[TE]
True (kinda). Definately the best way to increase participation is with 
tangible victories and benifits. Particularly poor people make very 
harsh and very necessary assessments of their options in terms of cost 
and benifit. This is fair enough. Only with wealth can you afford to 
repeat Uni, lose a job or suffer other possible consequences from 
failing to focus on your individual life. Realistically collective 
action has to show that it can work and is worth the risk.

[AL]
Above seems to be central problem for "Neither". Even leaving aside
questions of poverty and "risk" most people see no prospect of
sufficient "tangible victories and benefits" from a campaign to smash
the two party state to make it worth the trouble as opposed to getting
on with one's individual life and/or concentrating on other political
activities.

I believe the goal is winnable, necessary and would be of great benefit
to all other desirable political goals and that the feedback from the
1996 campaign showed this clearly. However most of my friends involved
in that campaign have not felt sufficiently enthused to do much about it
and in that atmosphere I have not even taken the obvious minimum steps
to write a series of clear explanations of why it is winnable, why it is
necessary, what the benefits would be and how we could go about winning.

My hope is that others will start work on that in this mailing list and
the knowledge that there are at least a few of us doing so seriously
will encourage each of those already convinced it is worth doing
(including myself) to do the work required to convince others. That is
clearly a necessary step which should result in interesting web pages
and other publications for wider publication. I suggest we should focus
on it.

[TE]
However I believe their are other impediments to the poor being 
political. None of these are inate or biological. The most significant 
one is the violent power of the state. I consider it a big lie that the 
"Hippys" and Activists of the 60's, and 70's merely mellowed or saw a 
lack of benifit in political organisation. Instead their leaders were 
jailed and silenced, beaten and killed. Their publications were banned 
and their employment terminated. There is little mystery as to why many 
poor people do not get organised or why poor organisations fail to 
transform society so often. Genuine emotional, social, financial and 
physical sanctions as well as all the military tactics of preventing 
communication, controlling information and corrupting spokespeople are 
deployed against the oppressed who attempt to organise.

[AL]
This simply isn't true in Australia (as opposed to some third world
countries).
There was some fairly mild repression here in the 1960s (mild beatings,
nobody killed, occasional gaol, more widespread but still marginal loss
of career prospects that would not seriously discourage anyone except
careerists). Most of the direct state repression was via drug busts etc
- not banning publications. That mild repression was certainly not the
explanation for the movement dying out here. On the contrary it was
easily dealt with and helped stimulate it.

Nor was the "ordinary" presssures of capitalist society which push
people to look for individual solutions rather than collective action
that might interfere with their job prospects etc sufficient to explain
why a movement which developed despite (and because of) those pressures
died out.

Since that period (now 3 decades ago) there has been even less overt
repression and 
although increased unemployment etc adds to the "ordinary" pressures of
capitalism it does not explain why people who were active then see "a
lack of benifit in political organisation" now.
Nor does it explain why the same age group that was active then has not
become active now, even if the previous generation had "mellowed".

Mythological claims about state repression only get in the way of
analysing the real problems.

We can publish whatever we like without the slightest fear of those
publications being banned or being gaoled for doing so. Moreover we have
easier facilities for doing so via the internet than ever before in
history. Tactics for "preventing communication" and "controlling
information" are less feasible than before. (Concerns about social
pressure and job discrimination etc are easily met by anonymous
publication).

The real problem is not having much to say.

"Corrupting spokespeople" has some relevance to that as a whole caste of
government funded do-gooders was created from the Whitlam period on
which has had a serious impact. But the real problem has been the
ideological bankruptcy of "left" politics.

Central to that has been the failure to draw a line of demarcation from
the ALP and the various pseudo-left ideas promoted by that caste, which
are widely regarded as being "left".

A fight to smash the two party state necessarily involves a sharp break
with the ALP and the caste that backs it. This is a necessity for any
serious left politics to emerge. It is achievable now because their
convergence with the Coalition has made them more unpopular than ever
before.

We cannot build a real alternative yet. But we can force a major change
from the current completely bankrupt two party state to an opening up of
political debate. Nobody is hammering them from the left (the
pseudo-left has no desire to and perhaps others fear strengthening the
right - which amounts to accepting ALP/pseudo-left claims that there is
something fundamentally more progressive about the ALP et al than their
opponents). By simply raising the banner of overt hostility to the two
party state and providing a focus for organization against it I believe
we can make a major contribution.

PS Sorry - still haven't caught up with old messages.

----------------------------------------------------------------
This is the Neither public email list, open for the public and general discussion.

To unsubscribe click here Mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]?Subject=unsubscribe
To subscribe click here Mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]?Subject=subscribe

For information and archives goto http://www.neither.org/lists/public-list.htm

Reply via email to