Re the debate about conspiracy theories, whistleblowers and sharp,
suspicious probing are essential to the people's immune system against
conspiratorial attacks on their interests. The most effective
immunosuppressant is the gibe "here we go again -- another conspiracy
theory nut".
If fortunes worth zillions of dollars can be protected and extended by their
owners conspiring together, and using the influence that gigabucks can buy,
it takes a very vivid imagination indeed to believe that they wouldn't do
so. Of course part of any such operation is to use some of this power and
influence to sow the notion that "conspiracy theories" are nut-case stuff,
and take advantage of the innate goodwill and trusting nature of honest
people, to con us into being diffident about suggesting they're up to
anything.
Conspiracies are like the mechanisms of chemical reaction. You can know
that sure as hell something is causing what you observe. You can know with
absolute certainty that there is a driving force, and measure it (ultimately
entropy increase related to system plus surroundings, for the
affictionados). You know there is a mechanism. But you'll never know
precisely in all detail what the mechanism is -- as precise mechanism is
always no more than a theory, not an observation. The more precisely you
try to define a mechanism the more easily your proposal is falsified. That
is the "conspiracy theory" trap, and if you are deaf to falsifications you
are no longer a purveyor of truth.
However, you can show with certainty what _can't_ be the mechanism -- using
a falsification precedure first proposed as central to scientific method by
Karl Popper -- and you can make a series of educated guesses about mechanism
(or about reality in any set of circumstances) which enjoy increasing
predictive validity. If none of that were so we wouldn't even still be in
the trees: the other animals would have had us for dinner.
The Port Arthur conspircay theory lacks credibility, not because it is a
conspiracy theory but because it posits a **particular** conspiracy for
which there is no evidence and which does not bear examination in the light
of known facts about the event.
It is extremely difficult to rebut convincingly the theory that the remarkable
universality of the globalisation-privatisation-deregualtion paradigm, and
the existence of so many career paths for pursuing it and so few for bucking
it, is driven by the interests of those that it pays the most -- and that
there are numerous conscious actions to ensure that the universality stays
that way. It is also extremely difficult to falsify the idea that such
actions (like MAI negotiations 1995-1997) would be kept behind closed
doors. And that,
ladees and jemmen, is (tatatata) a conspiracy theory! Much more credible
than any theory of random accumulation of ignorant dogma among the
world's economists, journos, officials and careerist pollies.
Australia's two-party (or three-party) sham fits perfectly in the general
notion in the second paragraph of this email.
Dion Giles
Fremantle
----------------------------------------------------------------
This is the Neither public email list, open for the public and general discussion.
To unsubscribe click here Mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]?Subject=unsubscribe
To subscribe click here Mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]?Subject=subscribe
For information and archives goto http://www.neither.org/lists/public-list.htm