At 23:19 26/10/98 +1100, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>Seems to me a different question entirely. How about this?
>
>"Neither rejects as criminal any attempt to coerce voters to vote in
>support
>of candidates who they choose to vote against, regardless of whether
>such
>criminal coercion is disguised as requirements to not use repeated
>preference
>numbers or by other means."
Fair enough - it's certainly much broader.
>1. Although OPV is slightly easier and simpler it is not difficult to
>write a number
>in every box and in particular it is not difficult to simply write the
>same (next highest)
>number in all the boxes that would have been left blank under OPV. Not
>many accidentally
>informal votes result from that requirement. (Most informal votes are
>deliberate and
>most accidental informal votes result from using ticks or crosses).
But, as you seemed to say, the difference is that repeating the number is
the same as leaving it blank.
>2. Experience has shown that far more "accidentally incomplete" votes
>result from OPV
>than the number of "accidentally informal" votes that result from CPV.
I would have thought that it wouldn't be possible for an OPV vote to be
accidentally incomplete?
>In fact CPV was
>originally introduced because of outrage over a state election held
>under OPV in a strongly
>anti-ALP seat where the ALP candidate won because too many voters for
>the several anti-ALP
>candidates failed to record their actual preferences fully and were
>surprised to discover
>that this resulted in none of the anti-ALP candidates being elected in a
>seat which they
>were certain was safely anti-ALP.
I see - fair enough.
In any case, unless you're prepared to kick out the OPV supporters, does it
matter whether we've got OPV vs CPV differences? (This question isn't
rhetorical, by the way).