Anne van Kesteren wrote:

On Fri, 03 Mar 2006 20:41:38 +0100, Jonas Sicking <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

I think there is need for some perspective here. Mozilla isn't broken in that .send doesn't work at all or that we in some cases have very broken behaviour. We simply follow DOM convention and have all the parameters to the function required even if they in some cases are not needed.


I agree with Karl, Mark, others and myself that the specification should be relevant in the future as well. It's now stated that implementations MUST support send() to be invoked without arguments. Specifically, the new text is:

 <p>Invoking <code>send()</code> without the <var>data</var> argument MUST
  give the same result as if it was invoked with <code>null</code> as
  argument.</p>

I just don't see the point in doing this, and I thougth we had all agreed on SHOULD. However at this point the entire issue is getting slightly silly and turning into a waste of all of our time as there are more important issues.

I just hope that tutorials will still urge people to pass null even for methods that don't need it.

/ Jonas

Reply via email to