Section 7.10.6 "Copy and 
paste"<http://dev.w3.org/html5/spec/Overview.html#copy-and-paste> of the HTML5 
spec suggests that "copy-and-paste is a form of drag-and-drop." It mandates 
that for a copy operation the user agent should act as if the user had 
initiated a drag on the current selection. Likewise, a cut should be a "drag" 
operation followed by a selection delete operation. Accordingly, a paste should 
be treated as a drop.

I would assume this concept should be applied to the events associated with 
these actions as well. Thus it would follow that a copy/cut operation would 
produce a drag event and a paste would produce a drop.

Is this really what we want? Most implementations (IE, Firefox, Safari, and 
Chrome) already have separate events for copy/cut/paste. While I see the 
similarities between the copy-and-paste and drag-and-drop, I don't believe that 
means they should be lumped together.  For example, what if a web page wishes 
to change the mouse cursor while a drag operation is occurring? You wouldn't 
want the mouse cursor to change in the same manner when text is copied to the 
clipboard.

In general, unless there is a significant savings in combining these two 
operations into one set of events, I think that they are best differentiated.

Thoughts?

Regards,

Jacob Rossi

Reply via email to