Greetings public-webapps,

I'm interested in feedback from imlementors about the lastModifiedDate 
attribute exposed on File objects.  The latest draft of the File API spec. 
describes an attribute "lastModified" which is no longer a Date object, but 
rather an integer representing milliseconds since the epoch (Unix Epoch).

TC-39 (which oversees ECMAScript) raised a number of issues with a Date 
attribute used as a property.  A lengthy exposé can be found in this email 
thread: http://esdiscuss.org/topic/frozen-date-objects

And note that "Date" within WebIDL itself is on shaky ground: 
https://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=22824

Among the problems with a Date property is that it is possible to have 
file.lastModifiedDate == file.lastModifiedDate test false (which is what 
happens in Gecko) and allowing modifications.

Mozilla is willing to remove lastModifiedDate completely, and migrate 
developers to file.lastModified, which is an attribute that returns an integer 
(long long) representing milliseconds since the epoch.  The Date API provides 
syntactic sugar for working with these integers, so I don't think the developer 
ergonomics resulting from the move from a Date object to an integer are too 
bad.  

If any other implementors have feedback about this change, we would like to 
hear it.  My proposal is to have developer facing documentation deprecate 
.lastModifiedDate and migrate web developers over to .lastModified.  The spec. 
will have .lastModified only.  Keeping both isn't desirable.

-- A*




Reply via email to