All,

In the process of "cleaning" up the spec and to make it ready to add more
important coverage (arbitrary format, private feeds), I identified that we
should probably remove the "hub.verify_token".

I'm not completely sure why it was initially added (Brett, Brad, Mart?),
but I think it was to facilitate the matching of a feed and subscription
for the subscriber who gets a verification of intent request. I believe
this can all be done thru the callback url, which (as per the good
practices) should be different for each subscription/feed.

I'm not sure how to submit changes to the protocol, but this would affect
the following sections :
6.1 : Removal of :

> hub.verify_token
> OPTIONAL. A subscriber-provided opaque token that will be echoed back in
> the verification request to assist the subscriber in identifying which
> subscription request is being verified. If this is not included, no token
> will be included in the verification request.

6.2 : Removal of :

> hub.verify_token
> OPTIONAL. The subscriber-provided opaque token from the corresponding
> subscription request, if one was provided.

6.2.1 Change of the first paragraph (remove the red):

>  The subscriber MUST confirm that the hub.topic and hub.verify_token 
> correspond
> to a pending subscription or unsubscription that it wishes to carry out.
> [...]

8.2 : Removal of section altogether.

Feedback?

Thanks!

Reply via email to