Hi,

I understand that Pyjamas/GWT widgets were created to build a more desktop
like GUI API.

These widgets essentially create/wrap plain HTML construct with nice OO
wrapper classes with lots of nice functionality for receiving events etc.

What I am unsure about though is what is to be gained from wrapping
existing javascript objects you want to use such as say the geospatial, or
websockets API.

These interfaces from what I can gather are quite adequate and I have
managed to use them directly using inline javascript ( using the JS()
function ).

It looks like the GWT guys would create wrapper classes I am assuming only
to create a JAVA esque API and the fact that Java is statically typed and
so is required.

The thing is I am not so sure it's worth doing this for Pyjamas, even if
you just port the GWT version of something because the API will have alot
of things unnecessary in Python/Javascript e.g. all the gettters and
setters.

Looking through the Pyjamas codebase it doesn't look like there has been
that many wrapper classes created and included that wrap Javascript
functionality outside the original GWT widget set.  Is this because people
just haven't been bothered to contribute back or is it because
Pyjamas/Python is just a much better fit for interfacing with Javascript
and so people just don't think it's worth doing any wrapping and just use
libraries directly using the JS() function.

Also why are there warnings within the comments for the JS() function
advising not to use it ?

One reason for me wrapping a library that I can think of is for
intellisense within an IDE, but even this might not be really worth it
because the API could change and this would require changes to the wrapper
classes etc. also usually interfacing to the libs is usually only a small
amount of the LOC of the full app.  Another reason could be that if there
REALLY is something you want to be careful interfacing with and REALLY want
to provide a more intelligent or simple API (FACADE) then it may be worth
creating python wrapper class.

What are peoples thoughts on this ?

Cheers

Reply via email to