Hi Lex, I completely agree that you can write sophisticated apps without doing what I describe. I also agree that pyjamas desktop is excellent for debugging etc.
I am interested in JS() calls and what other people are doing interfacing to Javascript libs because my application will require geolocation, and websockets/gae Channel API, local datastore among others. Also, I was under the impression you can't run Javascript under pyjd as it is pure python ? Cheers On Tue, Dec 6, 2011 at 6:02 PM, Lex Berezhny <[email protected]> wrote: > A lot of people, including myself, run pyjamas desktop in addition to > compiling to javascript. I prefer pyjd during development as it > provides for a very fast iterative approach. I've written some pretty > sophisticated widgets and apps so far without using any JS() calls > whatsoever. My app works in pyjd and in pyjs, development is a > pleasure because of this. > > - lex > > On Tue, Dec 6, 2011 at 12:48 PM, Apexi 200sx <[email protected]> > wrote: > > Hi, > > > > I understand that Pyjamas/GWT widgets were created to build a more > desktop > > like GUI API. > > > > These widgets essentially create/wrap plain HTML construct with nice OO > > wrapper classes with lots of nice functionality for receiving events etc. > > > > What I am unsure about though is what is to be gained from wrapping > existing > > javascript objects you want to use such as say the geospatial, or > websockets > > API. > > > > These interfaces from what I can gather are quite adequate and I have > > managed to use them directly using inline javascript ( using the JS() > > function ). > > > > It looks like the GWT guys would create wrapper classes I am assuming > only > > to create a JAVA esque API and the fact that Java is statically typed > and so > > is required. > > > > The thing is I am not so sure it's worth doing this for Pyjamas, even if > you > > just port the GWT version of something because the API will have alot of > > things unnecessary in Python/Javascript e.g. all the gettters and > setters. > > > > Looking through the Pyjamas codebase it doesn't look like there has been > > that many wrapper classes created and included that wrap Javascript > > functionality outside the original GWT widget set. Is this because > people > > just haven't been bothered to contribute back or is it because > > Pyjamas/Python is just a much better fit for interfacing with Javascript > and > > so people just don't think it's worth doing any wrapping and just use > > libraries directly using the JS() function. > > > > Also why are there warnings within the comments for the JS() function > > advising not to use it ? > > > > One reason for me wrapping a library that I can think of is for > intellisense > > within an IDE, but even this might not be really worth it because the API > > could change and this would require changes to the wrapper classes etc. > also > > usually interfacing to the libs is usually only a small amount of the > LOC of > > the full app. Another reason could be that if there REALLY is something > you > > want to be careful interfacing with and REALLY want to provide a more > > intelligent or simple API (FACADE) then it may be worth creating python > > wrapper class. > > > > What are peoples thoughts on this ? > > > > Cheers > > > > > > > > > > >

