On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 6:33 PM, Apexi 200sx <[email protected]> wrote:
> Hi Luke,
>
> I don't want to start an argument at all, I just want to try and understand
> where you're coming from.

 no problem.

> I am probably naive but what is pyjamas paying to have a project on
> sourceforge, or for having the mailing list on google ?

 zero monetary cost - that is not the point.  "free" has two meanings.
 let me put it this way.  if you were given a gift of blood diamonds,
would you accept them?  they're "free", right, so what's the problem?
you can accept a gift that cost somebody their life, can't you?

 ... after all, it doesn't cost _you_ anything, right?

 you see the point?  once you've taken on-board a principle - a moral
issue - you have to stick to it, and that really is the end of it.

 in the case of blood diamonds, the fact that somebody was murdered in
order to get those diamonds should really, really bother you... but
only if you believe that murder is wrong.

 if however you don't believe that murder is wrong, then sure, you
could easily accept the diamonds.

 it's the same thing here.  if you believe that non-free web services
are "wrong", then asking someone to just "go use those services, it
doesn't cause any harm, surely?" is very much like saying to them that
murder is somehow ok.


> I don't understand what is wrong with using tools from these companies, is
> it because they are not non-profit organisations ?

 there's a book written by the 2006 nobel peace prize winner,
professor muhammad yunus, called "creating a world without poverty".
he explains - patiently - the disdavantages of non-profit
organisations.  a non-profit organisation isn't an appropriate vehicle
either, so no that's not it.

 it really is as simple as "the source code of the web site is not
available" - but that is the conclusion, not the background.

 the background really is quite involved... let me see if i can find
an appropriate quote from rms, which describes _some_ of the issues -
entire article is here
http://broadcast.oreilly.com/2009/04/stallman-discusses-free-softwa.html

"Software as a service" means that you think of a particular server as
doing your computing for you. If that's what the server does, you must
not use it! If you do your computing on someone else's server, you
hand over control of your computing to whoever controls the server. It
is like running binary-only software, only worse: it's even harder for
you to patch the program that's running on someone else's server than
it is to patch a binary copy of a program running on your own
computer. Just like non-free software, "software as a service" is
incompatible with your freedom.

We did not try to address this with the GNU Affero GPL because this
cannot be solved by a software license. If all the software running on
the server is released free software, that would enable you to set up
a your own similar server if you wanted to; but you still have no
control when you use the server that isn't yours.

The only solution to this problem is not to use someone else's server
to do your own computing on your own data. Do it on your own computer,
using your own copy of a free program.


then, also, further down in the comments, this particular one caught my eye:

I understand why incompetent developers want to hold so passionately
to the power proprietary software gives them over the user. In a free
market dominated by free software you have to be GOOD to get WELL
paid. If you are not so good but know the basic skills reasonably
well, you will surely get paid. In any case, there is no risk of
starving. In his talks, Stallman explains why free software is not bad
for the economy. In fact, I think it's quite the opposite.

Anyway the point of free software is ETHICAL. You may disagree with
it. That's ok. But, please, do try to see that free software is NOT an
attack on the profession of software development but on a certain
model of software DISTRIBUTION.


lastly: if there's going to be any "ad-revenue", why *exactly* is it
"good" for the pyjamas project to be giving these companies -
code.google.com and sourceforge.net - the opportunity to make
advertising money *instead* of the pyjamas project??

there are tons of good reasons as well as moral issues involved.

"just because it's convenient" is *not* a good reason to abandon a
principle.  that's the slippery slope to hell.

l.

Reply via email to