On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 8:29 PM, Lex Berezhny <[email protected]> wrote:

> I don't understand the logic of using git because you respect the
> developers but then saying you're okay with switching to dulwich. Is
> dulwich written by the same developers as git?

 dulwich was written by some members of the samba team.  i trust their
thoroughness and programming skills to get dulwich right.

> If you're willing to switch to dulwich, why not switch to mercurial?

 because mercurial is not git.  other than that it's really hard for
me to explain.

 guys - there's some things that i just do instinctively /
intuitively, and it then takes me weeks, sometimes months and in a few
cases years (not joking) to come up with a full "rational" logical
explanation... but those instinctive "instant" decisions turn out to
save vast amounts of time and effort.  including - critically - _not_
having to go through the "rational and logical" route.

 aside from that: let me try to explain.

 picking git is one of those kinds of decisions where you just have to
look at who's behind the project, and see what their main focus is.
you have linus torvalds - one of the most gifted and respected - and
prominent - programmers on the planet, and even _he_ can't quite fully
explain the optimisations that he put into git in a rational and
logical way.  behind him, precisely because he is linus torvalds, a
team of exceptionally competent systems-level programmers also pitched
in to help maintain and develop git.

 any other revision control system simply cannot - has not - matched
that level of dedication and expertise.  there really is no
competition.

 beyond that: there are some areas of programming - system-level
programming is one of them - where taking the python "dogfood" thing
as an overall theme is just... a step too far, and for me i draw the
line at source / revision control.  and the reason for that is because
of limitations of python itself.  python can be 99% the speed of c in
many cases, and 1% the speed of c in others.  by the time you get to a
gigabyte revision controlled data store, the performance hit of python
just completely wipes out the project.

 ok yes i know that some people like to take python to extremes...
bloody 'ellfire, this is another james tauber project:

   https://github.com/jtauber/cleese/tree/master/necco/python

that's hilarious - james wrote an entire operating system that used
python (mostly)!

 then there's also http://unununium.org which again unfortunately (but
perhaps not surprisingly) has been abandoned.

 so.. yeah, you have to draw the line - sensibly - somewhere, and for
me that's at revision control.  web servers however - nooo problem.

l.

Reply via email to