On Thursday, December 08, 2011 09:06:45 PM Luke Kenneth Casson Leighton wrote:
> On Thu, Dec 8, 2011 at 6:33 PM, Apexi 200sx <[email protected]> wrote:
> > Hi Luke,
> > 
> > I don't want to start an argument at all, I just want to try and
> > understand where you're coming from.
> 
>  no problem.
> 
> > I am probably naive but what is pyjamas paying to have a project on
> > sourceforge, or for having the mailing list on google ?
> 
>  zero monetary cost - that is not the point.  "free" has two meanings.
>  let me put it this way.  if you were given a gift of blood diamonds,
> would you accept them?  they're "free", right, so what's the problem?
> you can accept a gift that cost somebody their life, can't you?
> 
>  ... after all, it doesn't cost _you_ anything, right?
> 
>  you see the point?  once you've taken on-board a principle - a moral
> issue - you have to stick to it, and that really is the end of it.
> 
>  in the case of blood diamonds, the fact that somebody was murdered in
> order to get those diamonds should really, really bother you... but
> only if you believe that murder is wrong.
> 
>  if however you don't believe that murder is wrong, then sure, you
> could easily accept the diamonds.
> 
>  it's the same thing here.  if you believe that non-free web services
> are "wrong", then asking someone to just "go use those services, it
> doesn't cause any harm, surely?" is very much like saying to them that
> murder is somehow ok.
> 
> > I don't understand what is wrong with using tools from these companies,
> > is it because they are not non-profit organisations ?
> 
>  there's a book written by the 2006 nobel peace prize winner,
> professor muhammad yunus, called "creating a world without poverty".
> he explains - patiently - the disdavantages of non-profit
> organisations.  a non-profit organisation isn't an appropriate vehicle
> either, so no that's not it.
> 
>  it really is as simple as "the source code of the web site is not
> available" - but that is the conclusion, not the background.
> 
>  the background really is quite involved... let me see if i can find
> an appropriate quote from rms, which describes _some_ of the issues -
> entire article is here
> http://broadcast.oreilly.com/2009/04/stallman-discusses-free-softwa.html
> 
> "Software as a service" means that you think of a particular server as
> doing your computing for you. If that's what the server does, you must
> not use it! If you do your computing on someone else's server, you
> hand over control of your computing to whoever controls the server. It
> is like running binary-only software, only worse: it's even harder for
> you to patch the program that's running on someone else's server than
> it is to patch a binary copy of a program running on your own
> computer. Just like non-free software, "software as a service" is
> incompatible with your freedom.
> 
> We did not try to address this with the GNU Affero GPL because this
> cannot be solved by a software license. If all the software running on
> the server is released free software, that would enable you to set up
> a your own similar server if you wanted to; but you still have no
> control when you use the server that isn't yours.
> 
> The only solution to this problem is not to use someone else's server
> to do your own computing on your own data. Do it on your own computer,
> using your own copy of a free program.
> 
> 
> then, also, further down in the comments, this particular one caught my
> eye:
> 
> I understand why incompetent developers want to hold so passionately
> to the power proprietary software gives them over the user. In a free
> market dominated by free software you have to be GOOD to get WELL
> paid. If you are not so good but know the basic skills reasonably
> well, you will surely get paid. In any case, there is no risk of
> starving. In his talks, Stallman explains why free software is not bad
> for the economy. In fact, I think it's quite the opposite.
> 
> Anyway the point of free software is ETHICAL. You may disagree with
> it. That's ok. But, please, do try to see that free software is NOT an
> attack on the profession of software development but on a certain
> model of software DISTRIBUTION.
> 
> 
> lastly: if there's going to be any "ad-revenue", why *exactly* is it
> "good" for the pyjamas project to be giving these companies -
> code.google.com and sourceforge.net - the opportunity to make
> advertising money *instead* of the pyjamas project??
> 
> there are tons of good reasons as well as moral issues involved.
> 
> "just because it's convenient" is *not* a good reason to abandon a
> principle.  that's the slippery slope to hell.
> 
+1

Regards,
Sebastian Hilbert

Reply via email to