On Mon, Dec 19, 2011 at 1:27 PM, lkcl luke <[email protected]> wrote: > On Mon, Dec 19, 2011 at 10:17 AM, Pascal Chambon <[email protected]> wrote: >> Hello, >> >> >> at the risk of feeding the troll, > > naah. i don't know what the word means. no, really, i don't > >> I'd like to dig deeper that recurrent >> issue which is blocking pyjamas sites in their current state. Sound more >> constructive to me than just concluding "dey djust craaaaazy" and moving >> elsewhere. > > :) > >>> so - in the context of politics, you are basically asking me "hey, do >> >>> you want to stop being an advocate of Freedom of Speech, and become a >> >>> Nazi or a Fascist instead?" >> >> >> >> On the contrary, if you allow me that analogy, I'm asking you to leave the >> sectarian communism-soaked world of "Everything which isn't FOSS doesn't >> exist" to enter a world of freedom, in which open-source projects can >> flourish using standard, rocksolid black-box tools like sourceforge, github >> and co, and pick all costless and harmless stuffs they’re offered. > > wonnderful :) yes. many right-wing americans have accused software > (libre) developers of being communist do-gooders and a threat to the > american god-given way to make money. > > >> So far I’ve not seen a single rational argument as to why >> software-as-service and closed-source softs would be FUNDAMENTALLY evil. > > ok, an analogy would be if someone was hanging by their fingertips in > a life-or-death situation, and you didn't take action. then you > claimed later that you "did not take any evil action", right? you > didn't go and stamp on their fingers so that they fell to their death, > so what's the problem, right? > > i think... more usefully, i think if you wish to truly understand > this, you should investigate why the Affero GPL was created. > > but factor 1 - it really does boil down to the fact that the code > behind those services is non-free. if pyjamas was not a web system, i > would say "get me its source code, and i will run it on pyjs.org, ok?" > > however given that pyjamas _is_ a web system, i cannot even let it > rest at that, because pyjamas _could_ do the job, therefore it must. > > it's that logically simple. > > thus, those services - when written as pyjamas applications - > *become* the examples. and, critically, they are examples of "being > the change that you want to see in the world". > > it really really is absolutely absolutely no use whatsoever to be > advertising somebody *else's* product, services or software, when your > *own* software is designed to do the same job.
Do these services compete with pyjamas? Pyjamas is a tool to create web applications and google groups for example is for news groups. To me they dont compete. In a non perfect world where we dont have unlimited resources, shouldnt we focus on making pyjamas the best it can be? The better pyjamas gets, the more people will it attract and then hopefully there will be resources to do all these other things? > > if you like, it is "shameful" to be using somebody else's code when > your own system should be doing the job. > > ok i can't spend any more time on this, i have a hell of a lot going > on right now. > > l. -- ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■

