On Mar 15, 12:39 am, Dennis Lee Bieber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On 14 Mar 2008 10:38:52 GMT, Antoon Pardon <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > declaimed the following in comp.lang.python: > > > In that case I find it very strange that when this question comes > > up, I see so few attempts to explain how the assignment acctually > > works. > > I'll probably get burned for this... but as far as I'm concerned, > assignment works very simply... At the very bottom of the name > resolution, assignment works by changing the left-hand-side "reference" > from any prior object for whatever object represents the result of the > right-hand-side. > > A bare LHS name is rebound in total. > lhs_name = rhs_expresssion > > A qualified LHS name (a name followed by a ".subname", or a > "[index]", or a "[keyvalue]") rebinds the specified subcomponent of > "name" -- that is, "name" remains bound to some object, and the > ".subname" (or "[index]" or "[keyvalue]") component of that object is > what is rebound to the RHS object. > lhs_name.subcomponent = rhs_expression > lhs_name[index] = rhs_expression > lhs_name[keyvalue] = rhs_expression > > No matter how many "." or "[]" sets appear, at the very bottom one > has focused down to a component, and that component get rebound from one > object to another object. > > In no case does the object originally bound get changed. FOR > assignment... Mutables using methods are a bit different... > > lhs.append(rhs) #assume a list > > adds a new element into the list, but it is still the same "list" (and > in that aspect, it is also a "qualified name").
You could warn if a name is assigned to twice-- maybe even error. Assignment is not a method. a= object() a= object() a is a name. it is a name of an object. what name? a. what object? that changes on demand. >>> a= 2 >>> a+= 2 >>> a 4 >>> a= (2,) >>> a+= (3,) >>> a (2, 3) >>> a= 2 >>> id( a ) # 1 505252512 >>> a+= 2 >>> id( a ) 505252544 # != >>> a 4 >>> a= (2,) >>> id( a ) # 2 11863472 >>> a+= (3,) >>> id( a ) # != 11933976 >>> a= [2] >>> id(a) # 3 11935296 >>> a+= [3] >>> id(a) # == 11935296 >>> += changed the id of a in the first two cases. It did not in the third. Assignment is not a method. Sometimes augmented assignment is. In the first two cases, the original was destroyed. In the third, the newcomer was destroyed. The newcomer was also destroyed in the first two. If you can write 'a' on an envelope and it goes to 244 White St., then assigning to a is an order to the post office: send 'a' to somewhere else. It doesn't change what it referred to before, though-- those letters are already delivered! There is ambiguity in 'change "a"'-- it can mean 'at the post office' or 'wherever letters address to "a" go to'. However, you can't change the entry of "a" with the post office of another scope. >>> "I want 'a' to be [3]." AmbiguityError: Use 'rearrange' or 'reroute'. >>> "Rearrange 'a'. Move out and move 3 in." a[:]= [3] >>> "Reroute 'a'. Move 3 in to the place wither mail to 'a' will go." a= [3] Some buildings have no entries at the post office. Some names don't either. You can change the contents of a building if you can send mail to it-- send a letter that says to change the contents! Other post offices keep their entries. >>> "Change another post office's entry for 'a'." No. >>> "Change mine." Ok! -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list
