Rick wrote:
[Rearrangee to put answer after question. Unless your name is Guido and you are making a short pronouncement that you want to be sure everyone sees, please do not toppost]

>>> My question to the mailing list is what am I doing wrong with my
>>> profiling that it shows such poor predictions?
[i wrote]
>> That *might* be easier to answer if you were to show exactly what you
>> did to get the odd-looking results ;-)

Sorry, I'm running the function:

def debugsuite():
    import profile,pstats
    profile.run('runsuite()','prof')
    prof = pstats.Stats('prof')
    prof.strip_dirs().sort_stats('time').print_stats(15)

where runsuite() runs the Hartree-Fock energy of a water molecule, and
is given by:


import unittest,logging
from PyQuante.CI import CIS
from PyQuante.Molecule import Molecule
from PyQuante.MP import MP2
from PyQuante.OEP import oep_hf,oep_hf_an
from PyQuante.PyQuante2 import SCF,SubspaceSolver,DmatSolver

As far as I could see, you only actually use Molecule and SCF


class UnitTests(unittest.TestCase):
    def setUp(self):
        from PyQuante.Molecule import Molecule

and you repeat the Molecule import here.

        self.h2o = Molecule('h2o',[(8,(0,0,0)),(1,(1.,0,0)),(1,
(0,1.,0))],
                            units="Angstrom")

    def testH2OHF(self):
        h2o_hf = SCF(self.h2o,method='HF')
        h2o_hf.iterate()

I presume that this is where the time goes.

        self.assertAlmostEqual(h2o_hf.energy,-76.011755864850628,4)

def runsuite(verbose=True):
    # To use psyco, uncomment this line:
    #import psyco; psyco.full()
    if verbose: verbosity=2
    else: verbosity=1
    # If you want more output, uncomment this line:
    #logging.basicConfig(format="%(message)s",level=logging.DEBUG)
    suite = unittest.TestLoader().loadTestsFromTestCase(UnitTests)
    unittest.TextTestRunner(verbosity=verbosity).run(suite)
    # Running without verbosity is equivalent to replacing the above
    # two lines with the following:
    #unittest.main()
    return

I presume in your overall time text, you ran the two versions of the algorith 'naked'. But, for some reason, you are profiling them embedded inside a test suite and runner. It does not seem that this should affect relative timing, but I have seen some pretty strange behaviors. At best, it will add noise.

Let me expand my question: what did you do differently between the two profile runs?

tjr

--
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Reply via email to