Chris Angelico wrote:
And it's illogical to say "Windows is feeling cranky today" when
something inexplicably fails.

Everyone understands that to be a tongue-in-cheek
metaphor for "Windows is misbehaving in unfathomable
ways", and not "the people who wrote Windows were
feeling cranky when they did it".

But ideas are not software -- they don't actively
*do* anything, so trying to anthropomorphise them
doesn't really work. It's hard not to read "this
idea is arrogant" as an implied criticism of the
person putting forward the idea, even if it wasn't
meant that way.

There are plenty of good ways of criticising an
idea that are clearly about the idea itself, so there
is no need to resort to adjectives that could be
misunderstood as veiled ad-hominem attacks.

--
Greg
--
https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Reply via email to