On 5/18/25 08:39, Mike Dewhirst via Python-list wrote:
Apologies for top-posting. It's my phone's fault.Since no-one appears to have
responded, I'll stir up some aggro and offer my opinion based on ~45 years
experience with Microsoft.Uninstall python/idle etc completely and download
from python.org instead. I would advise ignoring recommendations and install to
c:/python313 or whatever version suits. From then, I would establish a virtual
environment for each project and ignore Windows paths. The clever things built
into Windows specific kit have built-in assumptions which probably suit some
people but not you. Nor me.Good luck.Mike --Unsigned mail from my phone
I did respond and something went wrong with the copy that was supposed
to go to the list, still need to investigate why.
IDLE uses the directory it was started in. That's absolutely fine if
you're in a directory you want to work in, and you type "idle" to a
command-line shell.
If you launch IDLE, like any command, by clicking on an icon, the start
directory depends on how desktop-style launching works (it doesn't have
the context of a "current working directory" that you have in a shell),
and on configuration settings. Without configuration (whether by the
user explicitly, or by the way the launch icon is set up during program
installation), it's likely to be the location of the icon file, or some
other uninteresting place. It's not just Windows where problems have
happened with IDLE using current-directory that's not what folks expect
- you can find grumbles for Mac as well if you look on the Internet.
Configuring the launch directory for a command run via an icon is very
system-specific. On Windows you can configure the properties of the icon
(the real one, not the one in the launch menu, which is a shortcut)...
except, as in the OP's case, if you used the Store version, which is an
"app", where you apparently can't. Store apps have some special
restrictions, which, in my possibly slightly less radical opinion, means
the Python one is not really worth using.
So:
- start IDLE from a shell prompt (change directory first if you want a
special dev dir)
- use the python.org version and configure the launch dir via the icon
- use one of the many good editors/IDEs that handle all this stuff. yes
that's not a "battery includes" thing like IDLE is, but hey... there are
many of these, free, proprietary, or in between. A pair of
community-curated lists are at:
https://wiki.python.org/moin/IntegratedDevelopmentEnvironments
https://wiki.python.org/moin/PythonEditors
and there are also a several-digit number of internet sites that promise
"the Best Python Editors" and that kind of click-baity thing...
--
https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list
