Hello Lisbon!
I made short review of two very similar themes [1], as we decided to
joint them. It covers only basic set (without any plugin). As base for
merging I propose "gis" theme, as there are more plugin icons.
Simple voting system (1B, 2B, 3A, ...) will work you think?
Please add your comments Anita, if needed.
regards,
Robert
[1] http://robert.szczepanek.pl/tmp/theme.png
1:
A + consistent with next
2:
A + one vector sign in theme (see 15)
B + nicer (transparency)
3:
A - too small map sign
B - page/paper? sing
4: see 2
5:
A - <extend view>? not <pan>
B + consistent with cursor; recognizable
- not sharp
6:
B - from another theme
7:
B - from another theme
8,11-14:
A smooth
B sharp
9:
A + easy to scale as general <move> action (small sign in right bottom;
see one after 21 - move annotation)
10:
A + fits in action area -> reusable?
B + bigger
11-14: green (A) vs. white vertex (B) for "object to be processes"
B - why 8 and 9 without white vertex?
15:
A + simple message
16-17:
A - not clear message (16 taken from GIMP)
B - hard to recognize, 17 too dark
18:
A - too smal arrow
B - "i" in strange place
19:
A & B both are unclear
20-21:
A - not typical
B - bookmark (but spatial?); breaks "without perspective view" rule
22-25:
A + consistent
_______________________________________________
Qgis-developer mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/qgis-developer
