On 29 Jun 2004, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

> According to http://horde.net/~jwm/software/qmail/#verifyrcptto, 
> 
>       Sample control/domainxlations:
> 
>       example.net:example.com
>       anotherdomain.com:myfirstdomain.com 
> 
> I think this is one of solutions for multiple domains without many
> mailAlternateAddress etc. 

Yes, and it's a good solution.  But there are two issues:

1) the rewrite support I proposed (with a preliminary patch to show
   feasibility) is much more powerful than a simple 1-to-1
   translation.  

2) For my site, the domainxlations control file would be over 300
   lines because I have to list every host.  The rewrite file to
   achieve the same thing, which I wouldn't have to keep up to date
   in case new hosts are added, is 2-3 lines.

So I still think the control/rewrite support would be a better
solution for the general case.  Besides being more powerful, we're
also not reinventing the wheel with a new control file, using the
one from mess822 instead.

> I wonder why you don't have any interest in this patch...

I was not aware of the patch.  Thank you for noting it.

Ted

Reply via email to