Duncan Watson wrote:
> On Fri, Apr 14, 2000 at 11:14:55AM -0700, Aaron L. Meehan wrote:
> > Quoting Duncan Watson ([EMAIL PROTECTED]):
Why is is so difficoult, why am I getting conflicting messages
as to where the problem is?
> >
> > Even our qmail server (with UCE patches) would reject his mail.
> > It's arguable...
> >
> > Aaron
>
> There we go. I only looked for valid MX'ng. I also get the error you report
> albiet via nslookup and debug=1.
I will repeat how my mail works:
================================
1. All mail sent to the domain 'movielink.net.au' gets
pointed to the machine 'mail.movielink.net.au' via
an MX record with priority 20.
2. The IP address of 'mail.movielink.net.au' is listed
in an A record in the DNS. The IP address is
'203.44.8.251'.
3. The 'movielink.net.au' domain is hosted at
the DNS '203.2.193.124'.
4. Using nalookup in default mode fails if looking
up 'movielink.net.au'.
5. All mail is received just fine at our site.
6. All outgoing mail is sent via qmail-smtpd to
our firewall and "masqueraded" onto the internet
IP address '139.130.11.172'.
7. Qmail sais "HELO mail.movielink.net.au" and the receiver
replies ....xxx(may be forged).
Reverse lookup on IP '139.130.11.172' set to 'movielink.net.au'.
================================================================
'telnet guestmail.net 25' and used the 'HELO movielink.net.au'
then 'MAIL From:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
This fails with error "451 Sender domain must resolve..."
'telnet guestmail.net 25' and used the 'HELO mail.movielink.net.au'
then 'MAIL From:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
This fails with error "451 Sender domain must resolve..."
'telnet guestmail.net 25' and used the 'HELO mail.movielink.net.au'
then 'MAIL From:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
This fails with error "451 Sender domain must resolve..."
Reverse lookup on IP '139.130.11.172' set to 'mail.movielink.net.au'.
=====================================================================
'telnet guestmail.net 25' and used the 'HELO movielink.net.au'
then 'MAIL From:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
This fails with error "451 Sender domain must resolve..."
'telnet guestmail.net 25' and used the 'HELO mail.movielink.net.au'
then 'MAIL From:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
This fails with error "451 Sender domain must resolve..."
'telnet guestmail.net 25' and used the 'HELO mail.movielink.net.au'
then 'MAIL From:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
This is "OK".
I am lost....
>
>
> Anthony if you are still reading, this should be your solution. Fix you DNS
> not to die when providing this address record.
>
DNS records.
-----------
Server: oznet.ozemail.com.au
Address: 203.2.193.124
Non-authoritative answer:
movielink.net.au preference = 20, mail exchanger = mail.movielink.net.au
movielink.net.au preference = 50, mail exchanger = mail.mel.aone.net.au
movielink.net.au preference = 100, mail exchanger = mx1.mel.aone.net.au
movielink.net.au preference = 200, mail exchanger = mx2.syd.aone.net.au
movielink.net.au nameserver = ns0.mel.aone.net.au
movielink.net.au nameserver = ns1.mel.aone.net.au
movielink.net.au nameserver = ns2.syd.aone.net.au
movielink.net.au
origin = ns0.mel.aone.net.au
mail addr = hostmaster.aone.net.au
serial = 2000032800
refresh = 28800 (8H)
retry = 7200 (2H)
expire = 2592000 (4w2d)
minimum ttl = 86400 (1D)
Authoritative answers can be found from:
mail.movielink.net.au internet address = 203.44.8.251
mail.mel.aone.net.au internet address = 203.2.192.66
mx1.mel.aone.net.au internet address = 203.108.7.46
mx2.syd.aone.net.au internet address = 203.108.7.41
ns0.mel.aone.net.au internet address = 203.2.192.95
ns1.mel.aone.net.au internet address = 203.2.192.94
ns2.syd.aone.net.au internet address = 203.2.193.123
>
If someone could tel me where the problem is I would be happy.
Anthony
