On 24-Apr-2001 Johan Almqvist wrote:
> Seemingly, your problem is with sender domains in the message and the
> envelope, not with which SMTP host you use...
>
>> Using q(mail)sendmail and smtproutes as for above
>> I had this kind of responses:
>> --
>> Hi. This is the qmail-send program at linux.ik5bcu.ampr.org.
>> I'm afraid I wasn't able to deliver your message to the following addresses.
>> This is a permanent error; I've given up. Sorry it didn't work out.
>>
>> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
>> Connected to 199.183.24.194 but sender was rejected.
>> Remote host said: 553 5.4.3 For MAIL FROM address
>> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> the policy analysis reports DNS error with
>> your
>> source domain.
>
> This is pretty clear, isn't it?
It appears to me (excuse my ignorance) that my domain is not valid
so message is rejected.Infact mantaining the same configuration:
passing mail via qmail-sendmail but changing my ../defaulthost
to my amprnet domain=ik5bcu.ampr.org,mail was accepted regularly.
The problem on this case was that qmail sent MAILER-DAEMON infos
to ik5bcu(that is another separate machine)...
and not as I want to linux.ik5bcu(qmail machine).
Another unanderstable thing (to my low knowledge) is that if I
use qmail via SMTP all the problem disappears.
My MUA is set to show <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> in the FROM field,but I guess
this is not the cause of not accepted mail at vger that apparently
is a DNS cause.
> Use qmail-inject with the -f option to set the sender to the same thing
> that your MUA gives to qmail on SMTP...
Johan,using qmail with my MUA via SMTP I never had problems,
they happen if *I switch MUA to use sendmail*
I've seen a similar script here to use qmail-inject -f but it appears
not very simple to replicate here.
The big question now is :better with qmail-sendmail or qmail-SMTP?
TKS,Marco.
> -Johan
> --
> Johan Almqvist
> http://www.almqvist.net/johan/qmail/
