On Samstag, 13. Januar 2007 23:22 Peter J. Holzer wrote: > On 2007-01-13 22:48:11 +0100, Joe Knall wrote: > > On Sat, 2007-01-13 Hanno Hecker wrote: > > > Deny or accept this single recipient and all is fine. > > > > Sorry that's wrong > > [...] > > > client: > > [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~ $ echo test | mail -r [EMAIL PROTECTED] -s test41 > > [EMAIL PROTECTED],[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~ $ smtp-server: 550 relaying denied > > "/home/joe/dead.letter" 11/325 > > . . . message not sent. > > > > server (shortened): > > 31437 dispatching MAIL FROM: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > 31437 full from_parameter: FROM: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > 31437 from email address : [<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>] > > 31437 getting mail from <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > 31437 250 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, sender OK - how exciting to get > > mail from you! > > 31437 dispatching RCPT TO: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > 31437 to email address : [<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>] > > 31437 running plugin (rcpt): TestPlugin > > 31437 TestPlugin plugin: denyRecipient [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > 31437 Plugin TestPlugin, hook rcpt returned DENY, > > 31437 550 relaying denied > > 31437 running plugin (post-connection): TestPlugin > > 31437 Plugin TestPlugin, hook post-connection returned DONE, > > 31292 cleaning up after 31437 > > > > in this case (good-rcpt is alphabetically after bad-rcpt) good-rcpt > > is not checked by hook_rcpt at all, > > Yes, because the client never sends a RCPT > TO:<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>. (BTW, your client isn't > standard-conforming anyway: The space between ":" and "<" isn't > allowed) > > > instead the complete transaction is > > dropped, no queue. > > Yes, if the client drops the connection, there is little that the > server can do about it. Your client is severely broken. Replace it. > > > With other names (bad alphabetically after good) good is checked, > > get's a OK, then bad fails, cleanup, no queue. > > > > Is it a bug or am I missing something? > > It seems to be a bug in your mail client (probably your local MTA, > since mail doesn't normally deliver by SMTP. What kind of system is > this, which MTA are you using and what do the logs of the MTA say? > > hp
nail 11.25 7/29/05 on gentoo 2006.1 after exporting smtp=mail.example.com:2525 it delivers via smtp sorry, no logs Yes, it's differnt from when fetchmail sends mail (The space between ":" and "<"). Gonna test ssmtp tomorrow. Joe
