> Bernstein claims that this is a requirement of RFC 821. 

Now, i'm not sure what Bernstein wrote, but i doubt he wrote that
a MTA is not allowed to reject a mail at SMTP level.

> He claims that a 200 response is a guarantee that the mail has 
> been received so qmail-queue writes the mail to disk and reads 
> it back.  

But this has nothing to do with the case where a mail should
really be bounced. The real problem here is, that qmail has
strict privilege seperation and qmail-smtpd is unable to check
a recipient on purpose. Therefore it needs to accept the 
message first, and qmail-queue will bounce it, if necessary.

Regards
Michael

-- 
      It's an insane world, but i'm proud to be a part of it. -- Bill Hicks

Reply via email to