--- Begin Message ---
IT'S PART D YEAR ONE: STILL MUCH TO BE DONE

After one year's experience with Medicare Part D, many people remain confused 
and frustrated by the complexity and limitations of the benefit. Problems are 
difficult to resolve because of system failures, complicated data-sharing 
requirements among multiple entities, lack of useful and standardized 
information about plan benefits and appeal processes, and regulatory 
limitations that are more stringent than required by law.

The Center for Medicare Advocacy has prepared a Status Report based on the 
experiences of advocates and beneficiaries over the first year of Part D.  The 
beneficiary stories in the Report are illustrative of the many beneficiaries 
who are experiencing problems and high costs due, in large part, to the lack of 
uniformity in Medicare Part D.  The stories focus on particular aspects of Part 
D implementation - the failure of systems to ensure that low-income 
beneficiaries are enrolled in plans and receive their subsidies, the lack of 
useful information about benefit limitations to help beneficiaries plan, the 
failure of the system for withholding plan premiums from beneficiaries' Social 
Security checks, and the lack of uniform policies and procedures for seeking 
exceptions to formulary limitations.

Reflection on the issues underlying these problems confirms that beneficiaries 
would be better off with a redesigned benefit that is standardized, available 
throughout the country, and administered through the traditional Medicare 
program.  Such a system would be more valuable for more beneficiaries and more 
cost-effective for taxpayers.

Accordingly, the Center for Medicare Advocacy continues to call for systemic 
changes to Part D.  Our key recommendations include the following:

Recommendations for Congress:

1.  Congress should redesign Medicare Part D to create a benefit that is 
standardized, available throughout the country, and administered through the 
traditional Medicare program. Such a system would be more valuable for more 
beneficiaries and more cost-effective for taxpayers.

2. Congress should eliminate the Donut Hole. If the Donut Hole is not 
eliminated, Congress should, at a minimum, authorize payments by AIDS Drug 
Assistance Programs (ADAPs) programs and pharmaceutical assistance program 
(PAPs) to count towards the beneficiary out-of-pocket spending limit.

3. Congress should require Part D plans to give deference to the opinion of the 
beneficiary's attending physician when making coverage decisions and should 
require CMS to delete the provision to the contrary in its regulations [42 CFR§ 
423.578(f)].

4. Congress should authorize Part D coverage for off-label uses of drugs that 
are supported by peer-reviewed studies, are proven safe and effective over a 
substantial period of time, are covered by the beneficiary's state Medicaid 
program, or are listed in one of the three compendia currently included in the 
Medicare Act.

5. Congress should hold oversight hearings on the implementation of Part D. The 
hearings should include an inquiry into the special problems of dually eligible 
beneficiaries, the withholding of premiums by plans and Social Security, and 
CMS's role in setting and enforcing standards for plan participation.

6.  Congress should require CMS to expeditiously establish a full system of 
real time data-sharing among all entities involved in Part D. Congress should 
require CMS to report on its strategies to resolve these problems effectively 
and within a specific time period, and should require periodic status reports 
from CMS.  

Recommendations for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)

1. CMS should create a real time data-sharing system among all entities 
involved in Part D, and develop mandatory fail-safe systems to ensure that 
persons who are dually eligible for Medicare and Medicaid do not experience 
gaps in either their drug coverage or their low-income subsidy.

2. CMS should expand its point of service (POS) system to make its coverage 
available at the pharmacy for all dually eligible persons who experience plan 
enrollment and related drug dispensing problems at the pharmacy. Further, CMS 
should require pharmacies to use the POS system, and hold pharmacies harmless 
for good faith billings to the POS that turn out to be incorrect.

3. CMS and Part D plans should be required to provide beneficiaries with clear 
and accurate information about Part D, individual plan offerings, and in 
particular, about the Donut Hole coverage gap.  This information should include 
the following:

  -- Materials from CMS and the enrollee's plan that explain how the initial 
coverage limitation and beneficiary out-of-pocket expenses, including Donut 
Hole payments, are calculated should be mailed to beneficiaries;

  -- Monthly statements that clearly indicate the total amount of payments that 
have been made that count towards the individual's initial coverage limit and 
beneficiary out-of-pocket responsibilities should be mailed to beneficiaries; 
and  

  -- Monthly statements that indicate, after the initial coverage limit has 
been reached, all costs that continue to count towards the out-of-pocket limit 
in the Donut Hole and how much more is needed to reach catastrophic coverage 
should be mailed to beneficiaries. 

4. CMS should require plans to provide a written coverage determination 
electronically at the pharmacy whenever a drug is not covered. The written 
coverage determination must explain why the plan will not pay for a drug, 
describe beneficiary appeal rights, and explain how to request the next level 
of review.

5.  CMS should ensure that Part D plans comply with required appeals and 
grievance processes, that plan call centers respond appropriately to 
beneficiaries, and that Medicare "customer service" representatives provide 
accurate information and keep track of beneficiary complaints.

6. CMS should exercise its enforcement authority to take actions against Part D 
plans that do not provide adequate notice, fail to meet the regulatory time 
frames for deciding a coverage determination or an appeal, or fail to train 
their call center staff adequately.

Medicare is the most successful social insurance program in our nation's 
history.  The Center for Medicare Advocacy urges our policymakers to continue 
that success, rather than derail it.  Congress should redesign Part D using the 
real Medicare model rather than allowing it to be scattered to the whims of 
private plans.  Create a single, nationally uniform program equally available 
to all who qualify; a program like the one which has successfully served older 
people and those with disabilities for decades.

To print a .pdf of the full report, go to 
<http://www.medicareadvocacy.org/PartD_YearEndReport2006.1.10.07.pdf>.
______________________________________________________________________

It's year two... Is Part D any easier for you?

Send a letter telling your officals that you're tired of the confusion, and 
just want a simple, workable Medicare.  Go to 
<http://www.democracyinaction.org/dia/organizationsORG/fairmedicare/campaign.jsp?campaign_KEY=5465>
 now! 
______________________________________________________________________

If you would like to know more, please visit our News page at 
<http://www.medicareadvocacy.org/Page_News/Center_NewsMain.htm> for more 
information on this and many other current health care topics. All of this 
year's Alerts are available for viewing.

It is crucial that real voices be heard on health care issues. Please share 
your thoughts on Medicare, health insurance, and related issues. Visit us at 
<http://www.medicareadvocacy.org/TakeAction_BeneForum.htm> to tell your story. 
We welcome submissions of all types, from beneficiary stories to advocate 
triumphs and tribulations.

All our online services and information can be accessed from our home page at 
<http://www.medicareadvocacy.org.> Thank you for your help in advancing fair 
access to Medicare and health care.

If you feel you have received this message in error, would like an address 
corrected, or would like to add an address, simply reply to this email with the 
desired correction.

Copyright (c) 2006 Center for Medicare Advocacy, Inc
/*Your email ID. <diaEmailID='267323335' thread=5210/>--*/

--- End Message ---

Reply via email to